• 3 minutes Nucelar Deal Is Dead? Iran Distances Itself Further From ND, Alarming Russia And France
  • 5 minutes Don Jr. Tweets name Ukraine Whistleblower, Eric Ciaramella. Worked for CIA during Obama Administration, Hold over to Trump National Security Counsel under Gen McCallister, more . . . .
  • 9 minutes Shale pioneer Chesepeak will file bankruptcy soon. FINALLY ! The consolidation begins
  • 12 minutes China's Blueprint For Global Power
  • 3 hours Science: Only correct if it fits the popular narrative
  • 3 hours Crazy Stories From Round The World
  • 6 hours What are the odds of 4 U.S. politicians all having children working for Ukraine Gas Companies?
  • 11 hours EU has already lost the Trump vs. EU Trade War
  • 1 day Pioneer's Sheffield in Doghouse. Oil upset his bragging about Shale hurt prices. Now on campaign to lower expectations, prop up price.
  • 4 hours China's Renewables Boom Hits the Wall
  • 1 day ''Err ... but Trump ...?'' *sniff
  • 6 hours Do The World's Energy Policies Make Sense?
  • 5 hours Forget out-of-date 'dirty oil' smear, Alberta moving to be world's cleanest oil industry
  • 5 hours Impeachment Nonsense
  • 1 day Tesla Launches Faster Third Generation Supercharger
  • 10 hours Water, Trump, and Israel’s National Security
  • 1 day Passerby doused with flammable liquid and set on fire by peaceful protesters

Breaking News:

Russia Plans To Boost Crude Oil Exports

Alt Text

The Worst Oil Trades Ever Made

Wall Street is full of…

Alt Text

What The Market Is Overlooking In The Occidental Deal

Occidental Petroleum has caught a…

Nick Cunningham

Nick Cunningham

Nick Cunningham is an independent journalist, covering oil and gas, energy and environmental policy, and international politics. He is based in Portland, Oregon. 

More Info

Premium Content

Saudi Arabia's Final Attempt To Boost Aramco's Valuation

Saudi Arabia is gearing up for the Aramco IPO, pulling out all the stops to boost the company’s valuation. But it’s a desperate attempt that is riddled with risk.

Saudi Arabia is reportedly bullying the ultra-rich in the country to invest their money in the offering, a pressure campaign that has echoes in the 2017 Ritz-Carlton shakedown.

Aramco is also dangling the possibility of larger-than-advertised dividend payouts to investors. “Aramco management has stressed the possibility of additional distributions to shareholders above and beyond the minimum dividend pledge,” Bank of America Merrill Lynch said in a report for investors seen by the Financial Times. Higher dividends would be made possible by borrowing, while the notion is also hinged on some optimistic assumptions on higher oil prices and steady increases in free cash flow.

But major banks are still not coming through for Aramco, putting valuation ranges on the company well below the $2 trillion figure that Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman wants. “This is marketing material,” one banker told the FT, referring to the optimistic assumptions that Aramco is peddling regarding future oil prices.

Bank of America, for instance, says the company may be worth between $1.2 and $2.3 trillion, which, to be fair, would still produce a staggering number, although the range the bank offered is nebulously large. Related: How Much Oil Is Up For Grabs In Syria?

Some press reports suggest that MbS has come around to the idea of a lower valuation, perhaps in the range of $1.7 trillion. But, again, even that revised number could be overly optimistic. The danger is that the IPO flops and the share price slides, burning investors along the way. China may invest $5 to $10 billion in the company, but from China’s perspective, the investment serves geopolitical goals arguably as much or more than any financial outcome.

Ultimately, there are large questions surrounding the unique nature of Aramco, huge profits notwithstanding. The Abqaiq attack highlighted geopolitical risks to the company’s operations, revealing that a sizable portion of the country’s assets could be knocked out essentially overnight by an unexpected attack. That certainly has to be factored into the valuation of the company.

Meanwhile, Aramco can make promises to investors, but at the end of the day, the company and its shareholders would be entirely at the mercy of the King and his political goals, leaving little to no legal recourse for investors.

“For example, spending big to expand production capacity to maintain Saudi Arabia’s status as the world’s only real swing producer makes sense from a political standpoint; but for shareholders, spending money on spare capacity that may never be used makes little sense,” Torbjorn Soltvedt, principle MENA analysts at Verisk Maplecroft wrote in a recent note.

For the IPO to be successful, MbS may need to lower his sights even further. “A successful IPO is one that makes money for investors, not the one that commands the highest valuation,” Slava Breusov, a senior analyst at AllianceBernstein, told Bloomberg. Breusov added that Aramco is worth “way below $1.5 trillion.”

Related: Protect The Oil: Trump’s Top Priority In The Middle East

MbS likely feels intense pressure to pull off an IPO with a high valuation, but pursuing that track is risky. “So far, MBS has very few policy ‘wins’ under his belt. And on the other side of the ledger, there are several clear failures: stalemate in Yemen, a stalled Vision 2030 reform programme, and the September 2019 attacks against the heart of Saudi Arabia’s energy infrastructure,” Torbjorn Soltvedt from Verisk Maplecroft said. “Achieving a nominal USD2 trillion valuation through strong-arm tactics will be a hollow victory if it reinforces existing concerns over governance and the rule of law.”

Meanwhile, Saudi Arabia is offering up Aramco within days of the OPEC+ meeting in Vienna, complicating both events. The valuation of Aramco is influenced by oil prices, and Riyadh’s strategy in Vienna is, at this point, highly influenced by its desire for a successful IPO of Aramco.

Nevertheless, press reports at this stage suggest that OPEC+ is likely to roll over the cuts rather than deepen them, which makes sense to some degree. Aramco may benefit from higher prices stemming from a deeper cut, but it would also highlight the political nature behind the company’s decision-making.

MbS has a lot riding on the IPO and there is no shortage of risks and landmines that stand in the way. But one of the few things that is certain is that the valuation will fall short of his vision. “[D]espite a broad range of measures to boost Aramco’s valuation, the USD $2 trillion target is likely to be beyond reach,” Soltvedt from Verisk Maplecroft concluded.

By Nick Cunningham of Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:




Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage



Leave a comment
  • Mamdouh Salameh on November 09 2019 said:
    Does Saudi Arabia need an Aramco IPO? My answer as an international oil economist is an emphatic NO.

    When the Government of Saudi Arabia took total control of Aramco in 1988 and named it Saudi Aramco, the intention was to ensure that all decisions regarding oil policies, production, exploration and investment are taken by the Saudi government according to the needs of the country. Saudi Aramco is the jewel in the crown of the Saudi economy. If this is the case, why sell shares in it.

    Still, Saudi valuation of Aramco at $2 trillion is unrealistic and therefore beyond reach now or ever. Therefore to save face, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, could easily announce the withdrawal of the IPO altogether and tell the world that he has changed his mind about the IPO and that he now believes that Saudi Aramco will remain totally in the hands of Saudi Arabia. It will be a no loss of face whatsoever for the Crown Prince since he can easily tell the world that he will find assets to invest in the non-oil sector of the Saudi economy from alternative sources.

    Actually the Saudi Crown Prince could still go ahead with the implementation of his cherished Saudi Vision 2030 without the IPO. Ending the war in Yemen and phasing out the financial subsidies for gasoline, diesel, water and electricity along with the money he got from his anti-corruption drive at the Ritz-Carlton shakedown in 2017 and the saving from the fees the banks are charging for the handling of the IPO could easily add to more than $270 bn thus obviating the need for the IPO.

    Even without the IPO, Saudi Arabia will always be a magnet for global investments by virtue of its great oil wealth and the fact that it is the world’s only real swing producer.

    Therefore, my professional and sincere advice to Crown Prince Mohammed is to forgo the IPO altogether and focus on diversifying the Saudi economy from Saudi resources.

    Dr Mamdouh G Salameh
    International Oil Economist
    Visiting Professor of Energy Economics at ESCP Europe Business School, London

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play