• 4 minutes China 2019 - Orwell was 35 years out
  • 7 minutes Wonders of US Shale: US Shale Benefits: The U.S. leads global petroleum and natural gas production with record growth in 2018
  • 11 minutes Trump will capitulate on the trade war
  • 14 minutes Glory to Hong Kong
  • 42 mins China's Blueprint For Global Power
  • 2 hours Bloomberg: shale slowing. Third wave of shale coming.
  • 2 mins ABC of Brexit, economy wise, where to find sites, links to articles ?
  • 2 hours Yesterday Angela Merkel stopped Trump technology war on China – the moral of the story is do not eavesdrop on ladies with high ethical standards
  • 4 hours Brexit agreement
  • 11 mins Disenfranchised people are angry people - map of global electoral systems
  • 13 hours Boring! See Ya Clowns, And Have Fun In Germany
  • 2 hours Spain Is On The Edge...Clashes Between Catalonia And "Madrid"
  • 57 mins Erdogan Holds All The Cards ... 3.6 Million Of Them
  • 13 hours 5 Tweets That Change The World?
  • 16 hours the future
  • 13 hours Leftists crying to make oil patch illegal friendly: 'Broken system' starves U.S. oil boom of immigrant workers: CONGRESS DO YOUR JOBS INSTEAD OF PANDERING!
  • 12 hours USA Carried Out Secret Cyber Strike On Iran In Wake Of Saudi Oil Attack
Alt Text

Greed Or Incompetence: What’s Behind The California Power Cuts?

California’s electricity shutoffs are highlighting…

Alt Text

A Draconian Crackdown Looms Over Natural Gas

Natural Gas is coming up…

Irina Slav

Irina Slav

Irina is a writer for Oilprice.com with over a decade of experience writing on the oil and gas industry.

More Info

Premium Content

Will Keystone XL Ever See The Light Of Day?

Earlier this month, TransCanada said it had secured 20-year commitments for a total 500,000 bpd for the notorious Keystone XL pipeline that should carry Albertan heavy crude to U.S. refineries in the Midwest. The project received the support of the Alberta government as well. And yet TransCanada has not made a final investment decision on the project. Will it ever?

Keystone XL is a controversial project and is only getting more controversial with time as opposition against oil and gas infrastructure in North America grows. In November 2017, a group of environmental organizations claimed an important victory in their battle against the Keystone XL oil pipeline project. A federal judge granted approval for their lawsuit against the presidential administration for its decision to greenlight the project that was vetoed by the previous administration.

Then there’s regulation and permits. So far, TransCanada has cleared all major regulatory hurdles, although the last one proved tricky. After being dumped by the previous U.S. administration and revived last year by President Trump, Keystone XL scored a major win in November: the Nebraska Public Service Commission (PSC) gave the project the go-ahead.  

Related: $70 Oil Cripples European Refiners

Nebraska’s regulators, however, approved an order for the Mainline Alternative Route for the pipeline out of the three TransCanada had proposed— the other two being the company’s Preferred Route and the Sandhills Alternative Route. Now, TransCanada is reviewing the alternative route, which is longer than the one it prefers, and delaying its final decision.

Even the commitments that the company was so happy about securing may not be good enough. Financial Post’s Geoffrey Morgan recently wrote that while the Keystone XL commitments represent 60 percent of the pipeline’s 830,000-bpd capacity, commitments for another pending project — Kinder Morgan’s Trans Mountain expansion — have reached 80 percent of the future pipeline’s 708,000-bpd capacity. The difference in commitments becomes all the more significant against the background of a Canadian pipeline network that is already panting under the load, which is only going to become greater in the near term.

If that’s not enough to keep TransCanada’s executives nervous, here’s more. Currently, there is a shortage of pipeline capacity in Canada. To date, it stands at some 330,000 bpd, but by 2019 it is likely to swell to as much as 700,000 bpd. However, this shortage could turn into a surplus if TransCanada builds Keystone XL, Kinder Morgan builds the Trans Mountain expansion, and Enbridge completes the replacement of its Line 3 pipeline. Related: Largest Oil Consumers Not In A Rush To Hedge Crude

Apparently, the capacity shortage will be a temporary problem, and in about five or six years there will be no need for all three pipelines, of which Keystone XL seems the most controversial. There have been warnings that it may be obsolete before it is even built, and that there is no need for it anymore, as Albertan producers opt for rail to make up for capacity shortages.

It’s true that Albertan producers have been forced to sell their crude at a major discount. This is hurting them, but if analysts are right, producers will only have to bear this for a few more years. If forecasts that China and India will drive global crude oil demand growth, then Trans Mountain’s expansion would make more economical sense than Keystone XL. Yet that project faces no less opposition. In the end, it will perhaps be the less controversial pipeline that gets built, sending the other to die a natural death.

By Irina Slav for Oilprice.com

More Top Reads from Oilprice.com:

Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage

Leave a comment
  • Joe on January 24 2018 said:
    Build it and they will come. The latest bad boy on the block is the Suncor Fort Hills oil sands mining project. It's about to start and will ramp up to 194,000 bbls per day possibly by year end 2018.

    While they were doing a practice run, just tuning up the process, they produced 1.4 million bbls of bitumen. That may be the last open pit mine for a while, but there will be plenty more SAGD projects, producing bitumen from pairs of steamed wells.

    Obviously there will be protests, but let's hope sanity prevails.

  • Citizen Oil on January 26 2018 said:
    Kinder Morgans Trans Mountain faces even more challenges than XL. It is going through the most anti-fossil fuel province in Canada. They have yet to secure thousands of permits and have a lawsuit objecting every kilometre of the route. The NIMBYism in BC is some of the worst on this planet. The hippy's think they can sustain a GDP on marijuana and real estate values. I'd be surprised if any of these pipelines are built. We have an extremely week leader and until he goes this will be a big issue.

Leave a comment

Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play