• 4 minutes Ten Years of Plunging Solar Prices
  • 7 minutes Hydrogen Capable Natural Gas Turbines
  • 10 minutes World looks on in horror as Trump flails over pandemic despite claims US leads way
  • 13 minutes Large gas belt discovered in China
  • 46 mins Would bashing China solve all the problems of the United States
  • 3 hours Model 3 cheaper to buy than BMW 3 series.
  • 54 mins Thugs in Trumpistan
  • 6 hours China To Boost Oil & Gas Exploration, As EU Prepares To Commit Suicide
  • 4 hours Pompeo's Hong Kong
  • 5 hours Yale University Epidemiologist Publishes Paper on Major Benefits of Hydroxchloroquine for High-risk Outpatients. Quacksalvers like Fauci should put lives ahead of Politics
  • 46 mins China’s Oil Thirst Draws an Armada of Tankers
  • 3 hours Coronavirus hype biggest political hoax in history
  • 17 hours US-China tech competition accelerates: on Friday 05/15 new sanctions on Huawei, on Monday 05/18 Samsung chief visits China
  • 1 day COVID 19 May Be Less Deadly Than Flu Study Finds
  • 2 hours Chicago Threatens To Condemn - Possibly Demolish - Churches Defying Lockdown
  • 16 hours Income report showing potential future spending and economic growth
  • 18 hours The CDC confirms remarkably low coronavirus death rate. Where is the media?

Enbridge Line 5 Project Dealt Severe Blow In Michigan

The Governor of Michigan, Gretchen Whitmer, has ordered the suspension of all work on a tunnel beneath the Straits of Mackinac that’s part of a project for the replacement of a section of the Line 5 crude oil pipeline operated by Enbridge.

The order followed an opinion by the state’s new Attorney General, Dana Nessel, who said the bill that allowed the construction of the tunnel violated the state constitution because “it went beyond what the bill’s title reflected,” the Associated Press reports. The AG’s opinion has the force of a law unless a court overrules it, the AP notes.

Enbridge issued a response, stating “Enbridge worked in good faith with the Michigan government on the tunnel project,” adding, “We disagree with the Attorney General’s opinion and continue to believe in the benefits of the tunnel.”

The pipeline producer also noted that the project could help bt 'reducing the chance of a release of product to virtually zero,' 'preventing an anchor strike from a ship in the Straits of Mackinac,' and 'ensuring Michigan will continue to receive the economic benefits from Line 5.'

Last December, The Michigan Legislature approved the Great Lakes pipeline project that envisages the replacement of a section of Enbridge’s Line 5 pipeline, which is 65 years old, and agreed to set up a state authority to oversee the construction of a tunnel for a section of the new pipeline.

The new pipeline will replace two old ones and be set in a tunnel, to be drilled at a depth of 100 feet under the four-mile Straits of Macinac linking Lake Huron and Lake Michigan. As part of the deal, Enbridge will pay between US$350 and US$500 million for the construction of the tunnel for the pipeline. The project could take between 7 and 10 years to complete.

Related: Russia Balks At Continued Oil Production Cut Alliance with OPEC

Former Governor Rick Snyder was quick to secure support for the bill approving the project before he left office, but it seems that was not fast enough. Both the new Attorney General and Governor of Michigan made their opposition to the Line 5 replacement project part of their election campaign last year. Governor Whitmer even called for the decommissioning of the existing pipeline on the campaign trail.

Environmental concern about the area seems to be legitimate: a  report from a joint U.S.-Canadian advisory organization, the Science Advisory Board, suggested the Straits of Macinac is among more than a dozen locations in the region of the Great Lakes that are vulnerable to oil spills. However, proponents of the replacement project note that a new pipeline would be safer than the 65-old one. Line 5 carries crude oil and natural gas from Ontario to Wisconsin.

By Irina Slav for Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:

Join the discussion | Back to homepage

Leave a comment
  • Leonard Page on April 09 2019 said:
    pipelines are the best way to move oil. however placing them in the great lakes is insane. no alleged benefit is worth the risk of a spill. the problem with the tunnel law was that it authorized enbridge to keep pumping 23 million gallons a day thru the straits during the decade long tunnel build. when pumping crude, line 5 delivers 95% to sarnia; when it pumps NGL (propane) 98% goes to sarnia. dynamic risk study of 2017 said shutting down line 5 would mean only a pennies a gallon temp increase in michigan gas and propane prices. talk about a no-brainer!!

Leave a comment

Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News