• 13 hours Oil Prices Rise After API Reports Major Crude Draw
  • 14 hours Citgo President And 5 VPs Arrested On Embezzlement Charges
  • 14 hours Gazprom Speaks Out Against OPEC Production Cut Extension
  • 15 hours Statoil Looks To Lighter Oil To Boost Profitability
  • 16 hours Oil Billionaire Becomes Wind Energy’s Top Influencer
  • 17 hours Transneft Warns Urals Oil Quality Reaching Critical Levels
  • 18 hours Whitefish Energy Suspends Work In Puerto Rico
  • 19 hours U.S. Authorities Arrest Two On Major Energy Corruption Scheme
  • 1 day Thanksgiving Gas Prices At 3-Year High
  • 1 day Iraq’s Giant Majnoon Oilfield Attracts Attention Of Supermajors
  • 2 days South Iraq Oil Exports Close To Record High To Offset Kirkuk Drop
  • 2 days Iraqi Forces Find Mass Graves In Oil Wells Near Kirkuk
  • 2 days Chevron Joint Venture Signs $1.7B Oil, Gas Deal In Nigeria
  • 2 days Iraq Steps In To Offset Falling Venezuela Oil Production
  • 2 days ConocoPhillips Sets Price Ceiling For New Projects
  • 4 days Shell Oil Trading Head Steps Down After 29 Years
  • 4 days Higher Oil Prices Reduce North American Oil Bankruptcies
  • 5 days Statoil To Boost Exploration Drilling Offshore Norway In 2018
  • 5 days $1.6 Billion Canadian-US Hydropower Project Approved
  • 5 days Venezuela Officially In Default
  • 5 days Iran Prepares To Export LNG To Boost Trade Relations
  • 5 days Keystone Pipeline Leaks 5,000 Barrels Into Farmland
  • 5 days Saudi Oil Minister: Markets Will Not Rebalance By March
  • 5 days Obscure Dutch Firm Wins Venezuelan Oil Block As Debt Tensions Mount
  • 5 days Rosneft Announces Completion Of World’s Longest Well
  • 6 days Ecuador Won’t Ask Exemption From OPEC Oil Production Cuts
  • 6 days Norway’s $1 Trillion Wealth Fund Proposes To Ditch Oil Stocks
  • 6 days Ecuador Seeks To Clear Schlumberger Debt By End-November
  • 6 days Santos Admits It Rejected $7.2B Takeover Bid
  • 6 days U.S. Senate Panel Votes To Open Alaskan Refuge To Drilling
  • 6 days Africa’s Richest Woman Fired From Sonangol
  • 7 days Oil And Gas M&A Deal Appetite Highest Since 2013
  • 7 days Russian Hackers Target British Energy Industry
  • 7 days Venezuela Signs $3.15B Debt Restructuring Deal With Russia
  • 7 days DOJ: Protestors Interfering With Pipeline Construction Will Be Prosecuted
  • 7 days Lower Oil Prices Benefit European Refiners
  • 7 days World’s Biggest Private Equity Firm Raises $1 Billion To Invest In Oil
  • 8 days Oil Prices Tank After API Reports Strong Build In Crude Inventories
  • 8 days Iraq Oil Revenue Not Enough For Sustainable Development
  • 8 days Sudan In Talks With Foreign Oil Firms To Boost Crude Production
Alt Text

The IEA Is Grossly Overestimating Shale Growth

The IEA’s forecast that U.S.…

Alt Text

Is OPEC Deal Compliance About To Crash?

OPEC’s victory lap to celebrate…

The Vicious Circle of Oil Price Induced Recessions

The Vicious Circle of Oil Price Induced Recessions

Former Secretary of Labor Robert Reich recently warned that the U.S. is likely headed back into recession:

The Economic Truth That Nobody Will Admit: We’re Heading Back Toward a Double-Dip

Why aren’t Americans being told the truth about the economy? We’re heading in the
direction of a double dip — but you’d never know it if you listened to the upbeat messages coming out of Wall Street and Washington.

Consumers are 70 percent of the American economy, and consumer confidence is plummeting. It’s weaker today on average than at the lowest point of the Great Recession.

The Reuters/University of Michigan survey shows a 10 point decline in March — the tenth largest drop on record. Part of that drop is attributable to rising fuel and food prices. A separate Conference Board’s index of consumer confidence, just released, shows consumer confidence at a five-month low — and a large part is due to expectations of fewer jobs and lower wages in the months ahead.

So is Reich correct? Are we headed back toward recession? We should be so lucky.

What is a Recession?

Recession is generally defined according to changes in Gross Domestic Product (GDP). The rule of thumb is that two down quarters of GDP mark a recession, but there are many other indicators such as unemployment rate, inflation, and household incomes that all change predictably during a recession. (There is no standard definition of depression, but some suggested definitions are a recession lasting at least two years, or a real decline in GDP of at least 10%).

According to the Bureau of Economic Analysis, (BEA) real (inflation-adjusted) GDP grew 2.9% in 2010 after a 2.6% decline in 2009. Measured in 2010 dollars, the change in GDP from 2009 to 2010 amounts to $541 billion. However, you may recall that the U.S. government embarked upon a massive stimulus plan in order to spur economic activity, borrowing money to fund growth. According to the U.S. Treasury Department, the federal government increased spending by $543 billion in 2009 by implementing a number of new spending initiatives (e.g., the Cash for Clunkers program).

Essentially, this is like borrowing money from the bank to give yourself a pay raise. The caveat of course is that if you are already living beyond your means when you give yourself this debt-based pay raise, you are simply digging a deeper hole that must ultimately be paid back. So you cross your fingers and hope that you eventually get a real pay raise while maintaining enough financial discipline to use that money to pay off your debts. In the case of federal spending, we are essentially mortgaging the futures of our children in order to keep the economy growing today.

But stimulus programs aren’t a sustainable way to fuel economic growth. Ultimately that stimulus money has to be paid back — with interest. If consumer confidence is high, we spend more money which drives economic growth. But as Robert Reich showed, consumer confidence is falling, based partly on the rise of fuel prices and food prices (in itself partially driven by fuel prices).

The Long Recession

This leads me back to my “Long Recession” thesis. In a nutshell, there is a strong correlation between rising oil prices and recession. The reason for that is simple; as oil prices rise consumers are forced to spend more of their budgets on energy, leaving less to spend on other things. Because the U.S. is heavily dependent upon imported oil, much of the increased spending leaves the country to fuel growth in other countries. (Professor James Hamilton recently surveyed the relationship between spiking oil prices and economic downturns in Oil Shocks and Economic Recessions).

When there is an adequate excess of energy production capacity in the marketplace, price increases will bring more product onto the market and price increases can be moderated. This was the case a decade ago when several producers outside of OPEC could bring spare capacity onto the market as needed. But in 2011, it appears increasingly likely that global oil production outside of OPEC has peaked, or is at least very close to peaking (Merrill Lynch, IEA). In this case, OPEC would remain the sole entity that could significantly impact the price of oil (at least until their production peaks), and it is in their best financial interest to keep oil prices high, as long as demand remains high.

This situation is evident when one considers that despite the recession, oil prices remained at very high levels. There was some demand destruction in the U.S., but countries like India and China increased their demand, which kept prices high. As the U.S. moves out of recession, economic activity increases, and this increases demand for oil. That did in fact happen in 2010; after demand for oil in the U.S. declined in both 2008 and 2009, it grew in 2010 as we came out of recession. But with little spare capacity in the system, increased demand pushes prices back up, transferring money from consumers to oil exporters and slowing economic activity.

Consider that in 2000, the U.S. imported 9.1 million barrels of oil per day. By 2005, that had increased to 10.1 million barrels per day, but the average global oil price had also increased from $27.07 in 2000 t0 $49.87 in 2005 (data from EIA). In 2010, oil imports had fallen to 9.2 million barrels per day due to a combination of several factors, but the price had increased significantly to $77.68. So the money that flowed out of the U.S. to pay for oil increased by $75.7 billion per year between 2000 and 2005, and another $92 billion per year between 2005 and 2010.

While it is true that the value of U.S. exports also increased from 2000 to 2005 to 2010, the cost of oil now represents over 50% of the U.S. trade deficit. In 2000, that fraction was 24%, but by 2010 it had grown to 52%. This situation is not sustainable, and it is a grave long-term threat to the U.S. economy.


Recurring oil-price induced recessions will likely be a vicious circle, and won’t be easy to break. It is a new phenomenon that is largely unrecognized by our political leaders. In the past, expanding oil production kept oil prices in check and could in turn spur economic growth. Once oil production stops growing — or worse, starts declining — history is no longer a good guide for predicting sustained economic growth following recession. With little spare production capacity, growth puts pressure on oil prices, which puts the breaks on growth.

How can we break this cycle? It won’t be easy, and politics as usual will make it even more difficult. Ultimately we will have to have some real political leadership to address this situation instead of the typical predictable goals and pandering that we have had for decades.

Otherwise, Robert Reich’s projection will have turned out to be optimistic.

By. Robert Rapier

Source: R Squared Energy Blog

Back to homepage

Leave a comment
  • Anonymous on April 13 2011 said:
    I was touched - genuinely touched - by the moronic foreign secretary of the UK, opening a meeting in Qatar by talking about protecting civilians. If he and Sarkozy want to protect civilians, what about protecting those in London and Paris.These ignoramuses opened this business in Libya with the intention of getting a larger outflow of oil from Libya, and getting it soon. They failed, and now we are talking about a new recession.Oh yes. This is an interesting article. I just wish that our political leadership would take a look at it.

Leave a comment

Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News