• 3 minutes UAE says four vessels subjected to 'sabotage' near Fujairah port
  • 6 minutes Why is Strait of Hormuz the World's Most Important Oil Artery
  • 8 minutes OPEC is no longer an Apex Predator
  • 12 minutes Mueller Report Brings Into Focus Obama's Attempted Coup Against Trump
  • 4 hours Canada's Uncivil Oil War : 78% of Voters Cite *Energy* as the Top Issue
  • 4 hours Australia Election Summary: "This was the Climate Change Cult Election, and the Climate Change Cult Lost"
  • 46 mins Australian Voters Reject 'Climate Change' Politicians
  • 8 hours California Threatens Ban on ICE Cars
  • 8 hours China Downplays Chances For Trade Talks While U.S. Plays ‘Little Tricks’
  • 8 hours IMO2020 To scrub or not to scrub
  • 8 hours Did Saudi Arabia pull a "Jussie Smollett" and fake an attack on themselves to justify indiscriminate bombing on Yemen city population ?
  • 12 hours Global Warming Making The Rich Richer
  • 1 min Misunderstanding between USA and Iran the cause of current stand off, I call BS
  • 7 days How can Trump 'own' a trade war?
  • 7 days China, U.S. Hold 'Productive' Trade Talks In Beijing
  • 8 hours Wonders of Shale- Gas,bringing investments and jobs to the US
  • 4 mins DUG Rockies: Plenty Of Promise, Despite The Politics
  • 4 hours Some Good News on Climate Change Maybe
Alt Text

Meet America’s Newest $9 Trillion Climate Change Solution

Democratic Presidential hopeful and Washington…

Alt Text

Oil Markets Must Prepare For Maximum Fear

Oil prices this week are…

Irina Slav

Irina Slav

Irina is a writer for Oilprice.com with over a decade of experience writing on the oil and gas industry.

More Info

Trending Discussions

UK Torn Between Hydrogen And U.S. LNG

The United Kingdom is very diligent in its efforts to become a greener country. This year, local media were proud to report that electricity produced by wind and solar installations had overtaken that produced by nuclear power plants. Earlier this week, a gas distribution company, Cadent, announced it will invest more than US$1.2 billion (900 million pounds) in the construction of the first large-scale hydrogen fuel station network in the country. The list can go on and the message is clear: the UK wants to reduce its dependence on oil and gas, especially the latter, most of which it gets from Russia.

A fresh report from the Institution of Mechanical Engineers has suggested a way to reduce the country’s dependence on imported gas. The way involves hydrogen made using the excess energy produced by wind and solar installations and then stored in the national gas grid.

“This hydrogen can then be used in all areas of the energy system producing low emissions fuel for transport, reducing the CO2 emissions from the heating system, reused to generate electricity as well as a greener feedstock for industries such as ammonia and plastics production.”

The idea sounds lovely and timely, only in order to materialize, it looks like it will require some serious investment and cheaper power-to-gas technology to bring about the hydrogen economy the IME is calling for. This hydrogen economy has some strong proponents in Europe, but there is a lot of work to be done before it can serve as an alternative to the current economy.

Falling solar and wind technology costs are the main drivers of the hydrogen shift. The variety of applications for the element is also a major advantage that could stimulate investments. Yet there are also problems such as the cost of power-to-gas installations to date, and if we are being honest, natural gas is still there, and it’s still much cheaper.

According to some industry observers, U.S. LNG could derail the advent of the hydrogen economy in the UK. Exports of LNG from the United States to the UK have been expanding, and it seems that this expansion is a trend: the UK is a naturally attractive destination for U.S. LNG cargoes as it is closer than some Asian markets, and also because the UK is eager to diversify its sources of gas. Related: Permian Bottleneck Provides Huge Opportunity For Oil Traders

The hydrogen economy, to be achieved through a system approach as laid out in the IME’s report, will take a long time. A large-scale hydrogen network is certainly a step in the right direction, but it is one of many steps. The government must commit to the transition to make it happen—and this, too, will take time. Meanwhile, the country will continue to need LNG, and U.S. shale producers will be only too happy to supply more and more of it.

The change of scale suggested in the IME paper happens slowly, not just because of the inherent challenges listed above, but because of governments’ natural mistrust of new things, be they power-to-gas technologies or an entire approach to energy supply. First the new technologies need to prove that they can work far better than the old ones, and to do it more efficiently.

A hydrogen economy may be vastly superior to a gas-based one, but this needs to be proven. Gas, meanwhile, has nothing to prove. Gas works and it’s cheap. And because of this it can undermine the efforts of the IME and other proponents of the hydrogen economy. On the other hand, it could stimulate them into more innovation, which could eventually result in the replacement of gas with hydrogen.

By Irina Slav for Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:




Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage

Trending Discussions


Leave a comment
  • John Brown on May 13 2018 said:
    Seems simple to be. Transition to cheaper USA natural gas & away from Russian imports. Tax the natural gas at the point of sale & if hydrogen really makes sense dedicate the tax to helping pay for the transition to hydrogen.
  • IG on May 13 2018 said:
    UK is dumb as always, NET Power's pollution free nat gas power plants will be the future in the short term, till solar and wind can effectively take over for base load. Hydrogen is just explosions waiting to happen.
  • Bill Simpson on May 14 2018 said:
    Hydrogen is nothing but trouble. It is generally only used in industry when nothing else will work. But if cheap surplus electricity is available, it might be a good way to store energy for later use in fuel cells, if the cells can be produced without using too much platinum.
    Natural gas would probably be cheaper for a long time yet.
  • Leroy Essel on May 14 2018 said:
    The UK can be inspired by New Brunswick Power (NB Power) in Canada that is the first electric utility in the world that partnered with a US mature start-up company called Joi Scientific and their 21st-century "Hydrogen 2.0" technology. The article titled "Turning Seawater into Electricity" published on January 8, 2018 by CBC News-New Brunswick will be converting a former 450 Mega Watt Coal Fired Electric Power Plant into a highly competitive clean hydrogen fueled and highly competitive electric generator. Unlike LNG this hydrogen can be safely stored in the ocean water these giant ships float on.

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News