• 25 mins Thanksgiving Gas Prices At 3-Year High
  • 4 hours Iraq’s Giant Majnoon Oilfield Attracts Attention Of Supermajors
  • 6 hours South Iraq Oil Exports Close To Record High To Offset Kirkuk Drop
  • 10 hours Iraqi Forces Find Mass Graves In Oil Wells Near Kirkuk
  • 10 hours Chevron Joint Venture Signs $1.7B Oil, Gas Deal In Nigeria
  • 11 hours Iraq Steps In To Offset Falling Venezuela Oil Production
  • 13 hours ConocoPhillips Sets Price Ceiling For New Projects
  • 3 days Shell Oil Trading Head Steps Down After 29 Years
  • 3 days Higher Oil Prices Reduce North American Oil Bankruptcies
  • 3 days Statoil To Boost Exploration Drilling Offshore Norway In 2018
  • 3 days $1.6 Billion Canadian-US Hydropower Project Approved
  • 3 days Venezuela Officially In Default
  • 3 days Iran Prepares To Export LNG To Boost Trade Relations
  • 4 days Keystone Pipeline Leaks 5,000 Barrels Into Farmland
  • 4 days Saudi Oil Minister: Markets Will Not Rebalance By March
  • 4 days Obscure Dutch Firm Wins Venezuelan Oil Block As Debt Tensions Mount
  • 4 days Rosneft Announces Completion Of World’s Longest Well
  • 4 days Ecuador Won’t Ask Exemption From OPEC Oil Production Cuts
  • 4 days Norway’s $1 Trillion Wealth Fund Proposes To Ditch Oil Stocks
  • 4 days Ecuador Seeks To Clear Schlumberger Debt By End-November
  • 5 days Santos Admits It Rejected $7.2B Takeover Bid
  • 5 days U.S. Senate Panel Votes To Open Alaskan Refuge To Drilling
  • 5 days Africa’s Richest Woman Fired From Sonangol
  • 5 days Oil And Gas M&A Deal Appetite Highest Since 2013
  • 5 days Russian Hackers Target British Energy Industry
  • 5 days Venezuela Signs $3.15B Debt Restructuring Deal With Russia
  • 5 days DOJ: Protestors Interfering With Pipeline Construction Will Be Prosecuted
  • 5 days Lower Oil Prices Benefit European Refiners
  • 6 days World’s Biggest Private Equity Firm Raises $1 Billion To Invest In Oil
  • 6 days Oil Prices Tank After API Reports Strong Build In Crude Inventories
  • 6 days Iraq Oil Revenue Not Enough For Sustainable Development
  • 6 days Sudan In Talks With Foreign Oil Firms To Boost Crude Production
  • 6 days Shell: Four Oil Platforms Shut In Gulf Of Mexico After Fire
  • 6 days OPEC To Recruit New Members To Fight Market Imbalance
  • 7 days Green Groups Want Norway’s Arctic Oil Drilling Licenses Canceled
  • 7 days Venezuelan Oil Output Drops To Lowest In 28 Years
  • 7 days Shale Production Rises By 80,000 BPD In Latest EIA Forecasts
  • 7 days GE Considers Selling Baker Hughes Assets
  • 7 days Eni To Address Barents Sea Regulatory Breaches By Dec 11
  • 7 days Saudi Aramco To Invest $300 Billion In Upstream Projects

Breaking News:

Thanksgiving Gas Prices At 3-Year High

Alt Text

Google Gets There First: Autonomous Cars On The Road

Google’s self-driving car project, Waymo,…

Alt Text

Keystone XL Pipeline Gains Approval After A 9-Year Battle

Nebraskan regulators have approved the…

Alt Text

The Surprise Winners Of The Oil Price Rally

The recent rally in oil…

Philippe Casey

Philippe Casey

Philippe Casey is a bilingual graduate (English and French) of Georgetown University's McDonough School of Business where he double-majored in Finance and International Business. He…

More Info

Shale by Rail: A Lasting Phenomenon

Shale by Rail: A Lasting Phenomenon

Little over a century after the world-famous Spindletop gusher blackened the skies over Beaumont, Texas and ushered in an era of United States oil dominance, the country’s energy profile has drastically shifted once again due to the shale revolution. In 2009, the United States surpassed Russia as the world’s largest producer of natural gas. According to International Energy Agency projections, America will overtake Saudi Arabia in 2020 to become the top oil-producing nation. Additionally, late May saw domestic production exceed imports for the first time in 16 years, further fueling speculation that the US could be energy independent by 2030.  

It must be emphasized that the magnitude of the shale finds and consequent United States production boom was almost completely unanticipated, even by industry experts. This can be seen in the clear inability of aging US infrastructure to keep up with the resulting supply glut. The American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) recently gave domestic infrastructure a “D+” rating – a poignant condemnation of the status quo and a reminder of the important task that lies ahead.
Among other effects, these infrastructural constraints have initiated a fundamental shift in the global oil market. Historically, US-based West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude has traded at premium to the North Sea’s Brent crude and served as the global benchmark for reference pricing purposes. This is no longer the case. The large bottleneck at the landlocked storage facility in Cushing, Oklahoma has placed strong deflationary pressure on WTI. A detailed analysis of the subject can be found in a recent article of mine: The Shifting Dynamics of the Brent-WTI spread.  

If North American infrastructural constraints have yielded one clear winner, it is the railroads. With much of the production increases coming from remote locations in North Dakota and Alberta, there has been a major shortage of pipeline outlets for the glut of crude. Railroads have eagerly rushed to fill the gap in a phenomenon that is rapidly becoming known as “shale by rail.” Crude oil shipments on US Class I railroads have correspondingly increased over 3200% in the past five years. A Class I railroad is defined as a carrier with an operating revenue of more than $433.2 million.  Presently, there are seven such railroads operating in the United States. The American Society of Civil Engineers estimates that freight tonnage will increase 22% by 2035, rising from 12.5 billion tons to 15.3 billion tons.

Rail Carloads of Crude Oil

Railroads hold several advantages over pipelines. Firstly, pipelines only move crude at an average rate of 3 to 8 miles per hour, much slower than freight trains. When crude markets are in a state of backwardation – a scenario in which spot prices are higher than front-month futures prices due to a temporary supply squeeze – the speed of transportation is important. The crude that arrives first is the crude that captures the premium.

Related article: Canada's LNG Dream – Racing Ahead…at a Snail's Pace

Pipeline construction is also slower and more costly than railroad construction. Given the incredible rate of production increases during the shale boom, the ability to rapidly expand outtake capacity from these fields is critically important. Most producing fields have limited on-site storage capacity and a buildup can negatively impact crude prices.

Additionally, railroads offer delivery a degree of flexibility that cannot be matched by pipelines. The United States has some 160,000 miles of railroad track and 565 freight railroads. Though total petroleum pipeline mileage is slightly larger at 180,000, it is overwhelmingly concentrated along the Gulf Coast. The majority of states do not even have a crude pipeline running through them. It is also significant that no major pipeline network crosses the Rocky Mountains – this is one of the reasons why California’s energy prices are consistently elevated. With trains, crude can be moved from production point to any major demand hub in the lower-48 with relative ease. The increased favorability of rail over pipelines is especially evident at the Bakken. Rail takeaway capacity from the field is projected to have risen from 115,000 b/d at year-end 2010 to 1,120,000 b/d by year-end 2013, an increase of 9.7 times.
The shale boom’s impact on railroads has not been exclusively positive. As the percentage of oil and natural gas in the energy mix continues to rise, the coal industry has suffered collateral damage. In 2011, domestic coal consumption was lower than in 1996. The share of coal-fired power in the US energy mix has also fallen from 48.5% in 2007 to 37.4% in 2012. In response, industry players have looked to China, Brazil, and Europe (particularly the Netherlands and UK) as sources of demand replacement, seemingly with success – June 2013 saw US coal exports reach an all-time high of 13.6 million short tons. The shifting demand dynamics for coal, however, have caused a drop in its transportation by rail. Carloads of coal fell 11% between 2011 and 2012. This decline can be partially attributed to the fact that Baltimore, Maryland and Norfolk, Virginia – two of the largest coal exporting ports in the United States – are located in relatively close proximity to the Appalachian Coal Belt.

Skeptics say the July 6, 2013 derailment of a petroleum-carrying train in Quebec may signal the beginning of the end for “shale by rail.” The incident claimed 47 lives and destroyed much of a small town. Thankfully, a radical knee-jerk reaction has been rejected in favor of pragmatic reforms which will increase safety without unjustly crippling the railroad industry. The changes proposed by Canadian transport authorities are twofold: 1) trains carrying dangerous materials will require at least a two-man crew 2) trains carrying dangerous materials will not be allowed to be left unattended on a main track.  The implementation of these common sense measures is the right and reasonable response to a one-off occurrence. While tragic, the derailment is about as likely to end rail transport of crude oil as the Macondo Blowout was to ending offshore drilling in the Gulf of Mexico.

Despite the tragedy in Quebec and the decline of coal, the prognosis for the US railroad industry remains very favorable. Accompanying the increase in petroleum carloads has been an increase in industrial sand shipments, which have risen 160.77% between 2009 and 2012. The majority of this increase can be attributed to the movement of “frac sand” by rail. Frac sand is used in the hydraulic fracturing process to prevent the newly-formed fissures in the shale formation from closing up. A single horizontal well is thought to require between 3000 – 10,000 tons of sand. Consequently, production of frac sand has tripled over the last three years and railroads have been a primary beneficiary – unlike liquid petroleum products, sand cannot be moved through a pipeline.

Rail Carloads of Crude Industrial Sand

North America’s largest railroad in terms of revenue – Union Pacific – recently released earnings figures that reaffirm the positive impact of shale on the industry. Earnings per share (EPS) reached an all-time high of $2.37, up 13% from one year before and 49% from 2011. Operating revenue and operating income also recorded best-ever performances. This is a remarkable achievement for a company which dates back to 1862 – only one year after the outbreak of the American Civil War.  Not surprisingly, the destination of most crude carried by Union Pacific is the Gulf Coast, as indicated by the red triangles on the route map found at the bottom of this article. Union Pacific’s success is no outlier, however, and serves as a microcosm for the entire railroad industry. As seen below, the Dow Jones US Railroad Index (DJUSRR) has climbed nearly 220% in the past 4.5 years, more than doubling the performance of the S&P 500 over the same period.

Related article: The Battle for Balcombe

Railroad Index v Major Benchmarks

Over the next decade, increased pipeline infrastructure and a potential repeal of the Jones Act will gradually reduce the current dependence on railroads for the transport of crude. This is partly because pipeline transportation costs are, on average, lower than the cost of crude-by-rail. Indeed, this can be seen in the fact that rail transportation of Bakken crude from the Williston Basin to Albany, New York is estimated to cost $12 per barrel.  

Ramped-up shale oil production from Eagle Ford, the Bakken, and the Permian Basin – coupled with large-scale increases in bitumen production from Alberta – will ensure ample demand for railroad services over the coming years. Unconventional oil continues to outpace both infrastructure and expectations, and the flexibility afforded by rail will cement the industry’s critical role for the duration of the shale revolution.

Crude by Rail Routes

This piece will be the first in a multiple-part series examining the diverse effects of the US shale revolution. The next two pieces will be: 1) The Far East: The New Demand Hub for Crude Imports and 2) Shale Goes International – But Challenges Await.

By. Phil Casey

Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment

Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News