How much oil from Iran will be disrupted because of U.S. sanctions? American officials have gone back and forth on this, but many of the people who decide how much Iranian oil will be knocked offline are located in India and China.
In recent months, both India and China each purchased more than 600,000 bpd from Iran. Together, that amounts to about 60 percent of Iran’s oil exports, which makes them hugely important to the efficacy of U.S. sanctions.
It is unclear which way India will go. Because of its proximity, and its growing thirst for oil, India is a major buyer of Iranian oil. But the Indian government of Narendra Modi has had a positive relationship with both the Obama and Trump administrations, no small feat. While Trump has damaged the relationship between the U.S. and a lot of countries, India has managed to avoid his wrath.
That would likely change if India scoffed at U.S. sanctions on Iran and continued to import oil. But India’s need for imported oil puts it in a bind, especially with higher fuel prices causing some unease among its populace. It could be costlier to cut out purchases from Iran and buy oil elsewhere. And during the last round of sanctions, prior to the 2015 Iran nuclear deal, India was one of the few countries that continued to buy oil from Iran.
Since the U.S. scrapped the nuclear accord with Iran in May, reports suggest that Iran has offered India “virtually free shipping and an extended credit period of 60 days,” enticements intended to keep India from cutting off Iran. “We can buy Basra Heavy, Saudi or Kuwait oil to replace Iran. Finding replacement barrels is not a problem, but it has to give the best economic value,” a source in New Delhi told Reuters last month.
But other signs suggest that Modi’s government is moving to comply with Washington’s demands. In June, Reuters reported that India’s oil ministry told the country’s top refiners to prepare for a “drastic reduction or zero” imports of oil from Iran.
Related: Wood Mackenzie: Global Peak Oil Demand Expected In 2036
Some argue that India could import oil from the U.S., which would serve several purposes at once. It could provide India with an alternative source of oil, it would also cut the U.S. trade deficit with India, and it would create good will with the Trump administration as it goes on its trade warpath. India could conceivably win steel tariff exemptions if it complies with U.S. demands vis-à-vis Iran.
“The upcoming sanctions on Iran provide a golden opportunity to commercialize more U.S. oil in the Indian market,” Abhishek Kumar, a senior energy analyst at Interfax Energy in London, told Bloomberg. “Escalating trade tensions between the U.S. and China will also be conducive to more U.S. oil coming to the Indian market.”
China, on the other hand, is in an entirely different situation. Open trade war between the U.S. and China could actually push Beijing into buying more oil from Iran, not less. On top of that, with refiners in Europe, Japan and South Korea already beginning to curtail purchases from Iran, there is a lot of supply from Iran that is looking for a home. Iran will likely offer discounts to Chinese refiners, and China might readily scoop up ample supplies on the cheap. “We don’t have any problem selling our oil” to China, an Iranian official told the Wall Street Journal.
Even more enticing to China is the possibility of conducting the trade in yuan, which would serve the dual objective of elevating the Chinese currency and bolstering the Shanghai oil futures contract. Europe may even quietly support more Chinese purchases of Iranian oil in an effort to keep the nuclear deal alive.
Meanwhile, President Trump just threatened to escalate the trade war to yet a new level. In a CNBC interview that aired on Friday Trump said he was willing to slap tariffs on basically every imported good from China. "I'm ready to go to 500," Trump said, referring to the $505 billion in total U.S. imports from China last year.
Related: U.S. Poised To Ease Biofuel Quotas
Few analysts expect China to buckle under the pressure. The trade war would just intensify if Trump moves forward. Buying as much oil from Iran as possible would be one way of retaliating against Washington’s demands.
ADVERTISEMENT
To a large extent, the total volume of oil disrupted from Iran due to sanctions will be determined by how much the U.S. wants to tighten the screws. A State Department official said in June that the objective would be cutting Iranian oil exports to “zero,” comments that sent oil prices skyrocketing. Since then, the U.S. government has softened its tone somewhat, with Secretary of State Mike Pompeo suggesting that he would “consider” waiver requests.
However, even if the U.S. wants to apply “maximum pressure,” China and India, which together account for nearly two-thirds of Iran’s oil exports, still hold a lot of the cards.
By Nick Cunningham of Oilprice.com
More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:
- Goldman: Brent To Retest $80 This Year
- OPEC To Rule Oil Markets Till Peak Demand
- Is The U.S. Overly Dependent On Russian Oil?
India will never halt its imports of Iranian crude no matter what pressure the United States puts on it. India announced that it doesn’t recognize any sanctions but UN sanctions and that it will ignore US sanctions on Iran and continue to import Iranian crude. In a nut shell, India has been angling for a better deal from Iran and it got it.
Iran is reported to have offered India virtually free shipping of crude cagoes and an extended credit period of 60 days,” as enticements so as to continue buying Iranian crude. With oil prices on the rise, it could be costlier for India to cut out purchases from Iran and buy oil elsewhere. And during the last round of sanctions, prior to the 2015 Iran nuclear deal, India was one of the few countries that continued to buy oil from Iran. Moreover, India already has barter trade agreement with Iran to facilitate bilateral trade and bypass US sanctions.
China, on the other hand, is in an entirely different situation. China is not going to comply with US sanctions against Iran. With the United States intensifying its trade war against it, China would have an incentive to buy more Iranian crude as a way of retaliating against Washington and also bolstering the petro-yuan. Furthermore, Iran will likely offer significant discounts to China thus enticing it to scoop up ample supplies on the cheap.
US sanctions on Iran are doomed to fail for two reasons. One is that the overwhelming majority of nations of the world including US allies and major buyers of Iranian crude are against the principle of US sanctions in general and particularly the sanctions on Iran. They resent the tendency of the United States to slap sanctions on any country with which it doesn’t see eye to eye. Another reason is the petro-yuan which has virtually nullified the effectiveness of US sanctions and also provided a viable alternative to bypass the petrodollar altogether.
Dr Mamdouh G Salameh
International Oil Economist
Visiting Professor of Energy Economics at ESCP Europe Business School, London