• 5 minutes Malaysia's Petronas vs. Sarawak Court Case - Will It End Up In London Courts?
  • 9 minutes Sell out now or hold on?
  • 16 minutes Oil prices going down
  • 4 hours Oil prices going down
  • 33 mins Sell out now or hold on?
  • 9 hours After Three Decade Macedonia End Dispute With Greece, new name: the Republic of Northern Macedonia
  • 13 hours What If Canada Had Wind and Not Oilsands?
  • 8 hours Two Koreas Agree To March Together At Asian Games
  • 7 hours Oil and Trade War
  • 2 hours Malaysia's Petronas vs. Sarawak Court Case - Will It End Up In London Courts?
  • 1 hour When will oil demand start declining due to EVs?
  • 13 hours Australia mulls LNG import
  • 8 hours Geopolitical and Political Risks make their strong comeback to global oil and gas markets
  • 4 hours Trump Hits China With Tariffs On $50 Billion Of Goods
  • 1 day The Wonderful U.S. Oil Trade Deficit with Canada
  • 1 day We Need A Lasting Solution To The Lies Told By Big Oil and API
  • 1 day Another WTH? Example of Cheap Renewables
  • 24 hours The Permian Mystery
  • 18 hours No LNG Pipelines? Let the Trucks Roll In
Alt Text

Was This Just A Temporary Pullback In Oil?

Technical analysis shows that despite…

Alt Text

Oil Sinks Deeper On OPEC Concerns

The oil price rally has…

Alt Text

Iran: Oil Prices Could Jump To $140 On U.S. Sanctions

Iran’s OPEC governor Hossein Kazempour…

Nick Cunningham

Nick Cunningham

Nick Cunningham is a freelance writer on oil and gas, renewable energy, climate change, energy policy and geopolitics. He is based in Pittsburgh, PA.

More Info

Trending Discussions

This Critical Oil Price Divergence Could Boost US Exports

Barrels

The gap between the two most important oil benchmarks has widened recently, a symptom of the shifting oil supply/demand dynamics between the U.S. and the rest of the world.

For the past few years, Brent and WTI have traded very closely together, as both benchmarks reflect the crushing weight of oversupply. Prior to the market downturn in 2014, the spread between the two benchmarks was dictated much more by geopolitical whims. Brent, which reflects market conditions in Europe, the Middle East, Africa and parts of Asia – in essence a more internationally-oriented marker – rose and fell more sharply on geopolitical events. WTI, on the other hand, closely tracked U.S. conditions.

The dynamics were most visible during the Arab Spring back in 2011, when oil prices around the world spiked. The oil market was already tight, and fears of supply outages – and not just fears, but real outages, especially in Libya – pushed prices over $100 per barrel. But Brent was particularly affected, while WTI increased more modestly. The result was a blowout in the spread – Brent temporarily traded at a premium of nearly $30 per barrel over WTI.

But another reason was that the U.S. had a crude oil export ban in place at that time, right up through the end of 2015. Surging shale production was trapped within the U.S., which put downward pressure on WTI. Meanwhile, if global supply conditions tightened, Brent would feel the pinch much more than WTI.

After the oil price crash in 2014, the differences narrowed. The removal of the crude export ban in the U.S. at the end of 2015 also erased some of the differences in market conditions. The two benchmarks have closely tracked one another since then. Related: The Latest Red Flag For U.S. Shale

More recently, however, the difference has opened up again, although to be sure, not like pre-2014 levels. Brent is now trading at a more than $4 per barrel premium to WTI, which, save for some exceptions, is the highest gap in two years.

There are a couple of reasons for the wider spread. First, and arguably the most important, is the cuts from OPEC, which has reduced supply in Europe, the Middle East and Asia. Second, U.S. shale is coming back, which is putting downward pressure on WTI.

But there are a few more reasons why the difference has become more pronounced recently. The stockpile of crude in the North Sea is abating. Also, hedge funds have stepped up bullish bets on Brent relative to WTI, which could be exacerbating the spread.

At the same time, the IEA has estimated that global oil demand is set to grow by about 1.5 million barrels per day this year, but demand is coming almost entirely from developing countries, which would influence the Brent marker much more than WTI.

Another reason is that OPEC is cutting production this month – the cartel is on track to lower output by more than 400,000 bpd in August compared to July, according to PetroLogistics. Saudi Arabia said a few months ago that August would be the month when it started to cut exports.

(Click to enlarge)

(Click to enlarge) Related: The Next Oil Price Spike May Cripple The Industry

Ultimately, however, we are unlikely to ever return to the extremely wide differential between the two markers that was seen several years ago. Crude exports from the U.S. continue to rise, topping 1 million barrels per day at times earlier this summer. If the spread between Brent and WTI grows large enough, oil will flow out of the U.S. to take advantage of that arbitrage. That would push up WTI and drag down Brent, essentially forcing the two markers to converge on each other. In that sense, the differential can’t get too big, and won’t stay open for too long. The lifting of the crude export ban in the U.S. ensures this is the case.

But for now, the larger-than-usual spread as of late is a sign that supply is rising in the U.S. while market conditions are tightening elsewhere.

By Nick Cunningham, Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:




Back to homepage

Trending Discussions


Leave a comment
  • Douglas Thompson on August 22 2017 said:
    "But for now, the larger-than-usual spread as of late is a sign that supply is rising in the U.S. while market conditions are tightening elsewhere."

    I do not know how you draw this conclusion. Inventories have been plummeting in the US . The rest of the world is willing to pay much more than the US for crude.

    I would say that this is a sign that global inventories are contracting and supply is not keeping up.

    I believe many are pushing a false narrative about US production swamping global supply. If this is the case, why are world wide inventories dropping (particularly hard in the US)?
  • Citizen Oil on August 29 2017 said:
    Douglas, all lemmings think it's a great idea to follow what everybody else is doing. I cannot imagine being an oil market journalist where you have to write a daily report on what the market is doing and why. Cut and paste everybody else's drivel is the path of least resistance.

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News