• 1 min Kurdistan’s Oil Exports Still Below Pre-Conflict Levels
  • 2 hours Oil Production Cuts Taking A Toll On Russia’s Economy
  • 4 hours Aramco In Talks With Chinese Petrochemical Producers
  • 5 hours Federal Judge Grants Go-Ahead On Keystone XL Lawsuit
  • 7 hours Maduro Names Chavez’ Cousin As Citgo Boss
  • 13 hours Bidding Action Heats Up In UK’s Continental Shelf
  • 18 hours Keystone Pipeline Restart Still Unknown
  • 22 hours UK Offers North Sea Oil Producers Tax Relief To Boost Investment
  • 1 day Iraq Wants To Build Gas Pipeline To Kuwait In Blow To Shell
  • 1 day Trader Trafigura Raises Share Of Oil Purchases From State Firms
  • 1 day German Energy Group Uniper Rejects $9B Finnish Takeover Bid
  • 1 day Total Could Lose Big If It Pulls Out Of South Pars Deal
  • 1 day Dakota Watchdog Warns It Could Revoke Keystone XL Approval
  • 2 days Oil Prices Rise After API Reports Major Crude Draw
  • 2 days Citgo President And 5 VPs Arrested On Embezzlement Charges
  • 2 days Gazprom Speaks Out Against OPEC Production Cut Extension
  • 2 days Statoil Looks To Lighter Oil To Boost Profitability
  • 2 days Oil Billionaire Becomes Wind Energy’s Top Influencer
  • 2 days Transneft Warns Urals Oil Quality Reaching Critical Levels
  • 2 days Whitefish Energy Suspends Work In Puerto Rico
  • 2 days U.S. Authorities Arrest Two On Major Energy Corruption Scheme
  • 3 days Thanksgiving Gas Prices At 3-Year High
  • 3 days Iraq’s Giant Majnoon Oilfield Attracts Attention Of Supermajors
  • 3 days South Iraq Oil Exports Close To Record High To Offset Kirkuk Drop
  • 3 days Iraqi Forces Find Mass Graves In Oil Wells Near Kirkuk
  • 3 days Chevron Joint Venture Signs $1.7B Oil, Gas Deal In Nigeria
  • 3 days Iraq Steps In To Offset Falling Venezuela Oil Production
  • 3 days ConocoPhillips Sets Price Ceiling For New Projects
  • 6 days Shell Oil Trading Head Steps Down After 29 Years
  • 6 days Higher Oil Prices Reduce North American Oil Bankruptcies
  • 6 days Statoil To Boost Exploration Drilling Offshore Norway In 2018
  • 6 days $1.6 Billion Canadian-US Hydropower Project Approved
  • 6 days Venezuela Officially In Default
  • 6 days Iran Prepares To Export LNG To Boost Trade Relations
  • 6 days Keystone Pipeline Leaks 5,000 Barrels Into Farmland
  • 7 days Saudi Oil Minister: Markets Will Not Rebalance By March
  • 7 days Obscure Dutch Firm Wins Venezuelan Oil Block As Debt Tensions Mount
  • 7 days Rosneft Announces Completion Of World’s Longest Well
  • 7 days Ecuador Won’t Ask Exemption From OPEC Oil Production Cuts
  • 7 days Norway’s $1 Trillion Wealth Fund Proposes To Ditch Oil Stocks
Alt Text

Oil Prices Nosedive On Bearish IEA Report

Oil prices are cratering after…

Alt Text

Short Bets On Oil Spike Ahead Of OPEC Meeting

Short positions in Brent futures…

Alt Text

Has The Big Oil Fire Sale Started?

The world’s largest sovereign wealth…

Nick Cunningham

Nick Cunningham

Nick Cunningham is a freelance writer on oil and gas, renewable energy, climate change, energy policy and geopolitics. He is based in Pittsburgh, PA.

More Info

OPEC Cheating Will Cap Oil At $52

OPEC HQ Vienna

OPEC succeeded in pulling off what many thought was impossible, overcoming mutual disdain and mistrust to reach a deal on reducing its oil output. Oil prices skyrocketed on the news, up more than 12 percent since the agreement was announced last week. But what if there is much less to the deal than meets the eye? What if OPEC does not actually follow through on the promised production cuts?

Several days of strong price gains ran into a wall of skepticism on Tuesday, after fresh data showed that OPEC’s November production was much higher than anticipated. The cartel’s output jumped from 33.6-33.8 million barrels per day (mb/d) in October to a record high 34.19 mb/d in November. The gains came from Angola, Gabon, Indonesia, Libya, Nigeria, Iran and Iraq.

If OPEC is to succeed in bringing production down to its stated target of 32.5 mb/d by January, it will now need to cut 1.7 mb/d, not just the 1.2 mb/d that it announced last week. But a few of those countries (Libya, Nigeria, Indonesia) are exempted from the limits agreed upon in the latest deal. That means that the rest of OPEC will need to shoulder steeper cuts if the cartel is to hit the 32.5 mb/d threshold. However, the group did not discuss this contingency – who should cut even deeper – so there is little reason to think that any individual member will voluntarily cut more than they agreed to just so that the collective output comes in lower.

On top of all of that, two key OPEC countries exempted from the deal – Libya and Nigeria – have a large volume of oil production capacity offline. Libya has already added 200,000 barrels per day in production gains this year, taking output above 500,000 bpd. They are hoping to ultimately bring output up to 900,000 bpd next year. In a sign that they could be on their way to that target, ISIS was ousted from Sirte, its last major foothold in Libya. The war-torn country still suffers from a political vacuum and splintered allegiances, but the risk to supply is likely on the upside. Nigeria too has roughly 0.5 mb/d of capacity offline because of pipeline attacks. It won’t be easy but Nigeria could bring output back online in 2017. The two OPEC countries could overwhelm the effect of the deal.

That suggests that OPEC won’t actually bring output down to the stated level of 32.5 mb/d, which essentially means that OPEC oversold its deal to the oil markets. Recognizing that the Vienna deal is not as rock solid as previously thought, investors sold off oil on Tuesday, with WTI and Brent each down more than 2 percent. Related: How Russia Outsmarted OPEC

The OPEC deal may hit another stumbling block this weekend as negotiators are set to meet with non-OPEC countries to discuss their cuts. Non-OPEC producers agreed to cut an additional 600,000 barrels per day, and OPEC made their 1.2 mb/d in promised cuts contingent on non-OPEC participation. So far, four countries are set to attend (although 14 were invited), including Russia, Oman, Bahrain and Azerbaijan. Russia alone had agreed to slash 300,000 barrels per day from its production total.

But there are reasons to doubt that non-OPEC will be able to deliver. Russia’s oil production, for example, hit a post-Soviet record high in November at 11.21 mb/d, up roughly 500,000 barrels per day from August levels, just before Russia agreed in principle to cap production at the Algiers meeting. In that context, its cuts of 300,000 barrels per day seem much less impressive. Moreover, Russian officials said the cuts would be implemented gradually in 2016, not immediately in January as OPEC had hoped.

This sets up the possibility that this weekend’s OPEC/non-OPEC meeting could disappoint. OPEC’s Secretary-General Mohammad Barkindo is hyping the summit, saying the cooperation will be “the first time OPEC [and] non-OPEC will agree to a joint, binding supply-management agreement,” according to the WSJ. With expectations high, any faltering in the negotiations could undermine the bullish case for oil. "Will Russia cut 300,000?" former Saudi oil minister Ali al-Naimi said in reaction to the agreement last week. "I don’t know. In the past, they didn’t." Related: OPEC Winners: Iran Brags It Can Now Sell As Much Oil As It Wants

Others voiced similar skepticism after the deal was put in place. “It remains unclear to us which other non-OPEC producers might be willing to commit to or even claim production cuts,” JBC Energy, a Vienna-based oil consultancy, wrote in a research note. “Although OPEC officials spoke of a 300,000 barrel-a-day contribution from Russia towards an overall 600,000 barrel-a-day non-OPEC cut, we remain quite skeptical that this will actually happen.”

That brings up another possibility – that several or most of the participants, both OPEC and non-OPEC, cheat. The cartel has a poor track record of living up to production quotas.

Dennis Gartman, author of The Gartman Letter, told CNBC that OPEC will undoubtedly cheat on their agreement. “It’s only a matter of time until they do cheat…They’ll begin cheating by February or March. Always have, always shall. It’s not going to change.” Gartman also expressed skepticism about the broader rally in oil prices, citing a questionable commitment from Russia and the resurgence of U.S. shale. “Every fracker worth his money is going to make money at $56. They’re going to be hedging that aggressively. It’s going to be hard to push WTI much passed $52 [per barrel].”

Former Saudi oil minister Ali al-Naimi admitted last week following the historic deal that sometimes OPEC cuts are not all that they are cracked up to be. "The only tool they have is to constrain production," al-Naimi said at an event in Washington, D.C. "The unfortunate part is we tend to cheat."

By Nick Cunningham of Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:

Back to homepage

Leave a comment
  • Kr55 on December 06 2016 said:
    Great news for oil bulls. Gartman (Mr. "We Won't See $44 Again In My Lifetime") saying a cap at $52 is basically a guarantee that oil will be breaking $60 in the near future.
  • Bud on December 07 2016 said:
    Nick, do you have an updated chart of global depletion rates by field?
  • zorro6204 on December 18 2016 said:
    "Every fracker worth his money is going to make money at $56."

    He doesn't actually know that, no one does yet, we'll have to see how it plays out in 2017. He just says stuff like that for impact, there's no rational thought behind it.

Leave a comment

Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News