• 2 days Shell Oil Trading Head Steps Down After 29 Years
  • 3 days Higher Oil Prices Reduce North American Oil Bankruptcies
  • 3 days Statoil To Boost Exploration Drilling Offshore Norway In 2018
  • 3 days $1.6 Billion Canadian-US Hydropower Project Approved
  • 3 days Venezuela Officially In Default
  • 3 days Iran Prepares To Export LNG To Boost Trade Relations
  • 3 days Keystone Pipeline Leaks 5,000 Barrels Into Farmland
  • 3 days Saudi Oil Minister: Markets Will Not Rebalance By March
  • 3 days Obscure Dutch Firm Wins Venezuelan Oil Block As Debt Tensions Mount
  • 4 days Rosneft Announces Completion Of World’s Longest Well
  • 4 days Ecuador Won’t Ask Exemption From OPEC Oil Production Cuts
  • 4 days Norway’s $1 Trillion Wealth Fund Proposes To Ditch Oil Stocks
  • 4 days Ecuador Seeks To Clear Schlumberger Debt By End-November
  • 4 days Santos Admits It Rejected $7.2B Takeover Bid
  • 4 days U.S. Senate Panel Votes To Open Alaskan Refuge To Drilling
  • 4 days Africa’s Richest Woman Fired From Sonangol
  • 5 days Oil And Gas M&A Deal Appetite Highest Since 2013
  • 5 days Russian Hackers Target British Energy Industry
  • 5 days Venezuela Signs $3.15B Debt Restructuring Deal With Russia
  • 5 days DOJ: Protestors Interfering With Pipeline Construction Will Be Prosecuted
  • 5 days Lower Oil Prices Benefit European Refiners
  • 5 days World’s Biggest Private Equity Firm Raises $1 Billion To Invest In Oil
  • 6 days Oil Prices Tank After API Reports Strong Build In Crude Inventories
  • 6 days Iraq Oil Revenue Not Enough For Sustainable Development
  • 6 days Sudan In Talks With Foreign Oil Firms To Boost Crude Production
  • 6 days Shell: Four Oil Platforms Shut In Gulf Of Mexico After Fire
  • 6 days OPEC To Recruit New Members To Fight Market Imbalance
  • 6 days Green Groups Want Norway’s Arctic Oil Drilling Licenses Canceled
  • 6 days Venezuelan Oil Output Drops To Lowest In 28 Years
  • 6 days Shale Production Rises By 80,000 BPD In Latest EIA Forecasts
  • 7 days GE Considers Selling Baker Hughes Assets
  • 7 days Eni To Address Barents Sea Regulatory Breaches By Dec 11
  • 7 days Saudi Aramco To Invest $300 Billion In Upstream Projects
  • 7 days Aramco To List Shares In Hong Kong ‘For Sure’
  • 7 days BP CEO Sees Venezuela As Oil’s Wildcard
  • 7 days Iran Denies Involvement In Bahrain Oil Pipeline Blast
  • 9 days The Oil Rig Drilling 10 Miles Under The Sea
  • 10 days Baghdad Agrees To Ship Kirkuk Oil To Iran
  • 10 days Another Group Joins Niger Delta Avengers’ Ceasefire Boycott
  • 10 days Italy Looks To Phase Out Coal-Fired Electricity By 2025
Alt Text

Ignore The Hype: Oil Is Still In A Bear Market

Sentiment in the oil market…

Alt Text

The Undisputed Leader Of Tomorrow’s Oil & Gas Markets

According to the Executive Director…

Alt Text

GE Looks To Divest Energy Assets As Turmoil Continues

General Electric’s turmoil continues as…

Leonard Hyman & William Tilles

Leonard Hyman & William Tilles

Leonard S. Hyman is an economist and financial analyst specializing in the energy sector. He headed utility equity research at a major brokerage house and…

More Info

World’s Smartest Investor Outperforms With Boring Utilities

Buffett

Warren Buffet doesn't need the likes of us touting his investment acumen. His holding company, Berkshire Hathaway, has compiled a stunning record of achievement over many decades, beating broad stock mar-ket indices handily while acquiring some of the dullest companies in the world. Like other insurance com-panies, Berkshire has very large sums of policyholders money to invest for the long term against future claims. And like other insurers, it's tough to find acceptable lower risk or fixed income investments in this world of ultra-low or negative interest rates and high stock prices.

But several years ago, Buffet began steering Berkshire into investments unusual for a financial concern. He purchased a number of regulated electric utilities and a railroad, the Burlington Northern. These invest-ments have much in common. They provide essential services in slow growing markets. They generate steady albeit modest returns. They require ongoing, large capital investments to maintain current levels of service and, as long as investment takes place, they generate substantial income tax deferrals that can also be invested profitably. Since these businesses are growing, at least in term of their assets--and some level of profitability is virtually assured--the owner or investor can still reinvest their capital at a reasonable re-turn. They don’t have to worry about the vagaries of public markets equity or fixed income. They can in-vest in themselves so to speak.

If Buffet is one of the world’s most successful investors, judging from the above examples, he achieved that title at least in part by only accepting a return that exceeded the risk he believed he was taking. That is, if investment X required a 10 percent return due to the risk inherent in it, and the shares offered a 10 percent return, Buffet kept his wallet in his pocket. But if the investment had a cost of capital of say 9 per-cent but he thought he could earn 13 percent, he was all in. Simply stated he sought a return in excess of his cost of capital.

Okay, so much for the classroom stuff. In the U.S. electric utility industry, recent commission rate orders have been finding that utilities should be permitted to earn around 9-10 percent on shareholder invest-ment. Regulators have determined that figure represents the appropriate cost of equity capital. Related: Why Big Oil Is Shying Away From Mexico’s Latest Oil Auction

Financial theorists, looking at government bond markets in which yields have literally dwindled to nothing on risk free investments, think that the cost of utility equity capital may in fact be closer to 6 percent. (This assumes an equity risk premium of 4 percent over the risk free bond yield of roughly 2 percent.) Clearly there is a wide discrepancy between currently authorized 9-10 percent returns and our postulated 6 per-cent. If regulators come to adopt these lower return levels--down go utility earnings.

Let's get away from depressing financial theory. Instead let’s look at what Berkshire Hathaway actually paid for utility-like assets and what it accepts as a presumably adequate return on its equity. Berkshire Hathaway lumps railroad and utilities together but we believe both the railroad and utility segments have followed similar patterns of profitability. The financial reporting does not spell out everything we would like to know but provides enough data to make reasonable estimates.

We estimate the underlying utility and railroad assets earned decent returns on equity of 9.8 percent in 2015 and 10.0 percent in 2014. But, Berkshire paid a substantial premium over book value in order to buy these assets. On the basis of what Berkshire paid (and Berkshire paid above market prices) we estimate that these investments produced a 6.8 percent return on equity in 2015 and a 7.3 percent return in 2014. (A study earlier this year from Semper Augustus Investment Group indicated that the utilities earned lower returns than the railroad.)

Bottom line? If these returns were not satisfactory, would Berkshire reinvest considerable sums into oper-ations and expand the utility operation through additional purchases? The question answers itself. We see Warren Buffet’s embrace of dull companies offering low returns as another indicator of what the cost of capital really is in the sector. As evidence it is far more compelling to us than a shelf of academic studies on the topic. These seemingly low returns, with their accompanying low risk, appear to satisfy one of the world’s savviest investors. We think that says a lot.

By Leonard Hyman and William Tilles

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:




Back to homepage


Leave a comment

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News