• 35 mins Uber CEO sees commercialization of flying taxis within a decade
  • 20 hours Theresa May Wants To Extend The Brexit Transition
  • 7 hours Plastic bans to dent oil demand growth-BP
  • 27 mins US admin to kill Energy Star program
  • 18 mins As Trump Trashes NAFTA, Mexico Turns To Brazilian Corn
  • 23 hours Iran To Recover War Losses By Exploiting Syria Natural Resource !?
  • 14 hours Apple in Talks to Buy Cobalt Directly From Miners
  • 15 hours German Neo-Nazis Are Trying To Infiltrate Daimler: Works Council
  • 14 hours Ideas on demand
  • 11 hours Nigeria freaking out about US "abandoning" its crude
  • 19 hours NASA Spends $1 Billion For a Launch Tower That leans, May Only be Used Once
  • 24 hours Tesla's cloud hacked, used to mine cryptocurrency
  • 14 hours Vanadium: The Next Star in Batteries?
  • 18 hours Venezuela's New Bitcoin: An Ingenious Plan or Worthless Cryptocurrency?
  • 24 hours We're worried about US shale production, while OPEC calls for $10 trillion investment to meet demand?
  • 17 hours API Inventory Data (Tuesdays)
Alt Text

Uzbekistan Races To Boost Energy Production

Encouraging developments in Uzbekistan’s attention-starved…

Alt Text

Is The Yamal LNG Project Overhyped?

The Yamal LNG project has…

Robert Rapier

Robert Rapier

More Info

Trending Discussions

OPEC Seeks Help From U.S. Shale

OPEC

Last week some comments from OPEC Secretary General Mohammed Barkindo signaled that OPEC may not understand how the U.S. oil industry functions.

Reuters reports that Barkindo urged cooperation from U.S. shale oil producers to help keep the global oil market out of an oversupply situation. Barkindo stated, “We urge our friends, in the shale basins of North America to take this shared responsibility with all seriousness it deserves, as one of the key lessons learnt from the current unique supply-driven cycle.”

Shale Producers Are Not A Cartel

But the U.S. oil industry is nothing like OPEC. In 2016, the 14-member countries of OPEC produced nearly 43 percent of the world’s oil. The cartel also controls 71.5 percent of the world’s oil reserves.

In comparison, the U.S. produced 13.4 percent of the world’s oil last year. That’s significantly more than any OPEC member except Saudi Arabia, but there are thousands of companies, each acting in its self-interest, responsible for U.S. oil production. In Saudi Arabia, one company — Saudi Aramco — was responsible for as much production as all U.S. producers combined.

Related: Big Oil Refuses To Give Up On The Barents Sea

Each of the U.S. producers acting individually can only impact a fraction of a percentage of the world oil market. Without significant collusion, U.S. oil producers just can’t affect the global oil balance in the way OPEC seems to think they can.

Yes, by increasing production — particularly shale oil production — the U.S. has added to the global oil glut. But there is no mechanism by which they can (legally) restrict production to benefit all producers. Production restrictions in the U.S. are a function of the collective decisions of those thousands of oil producers, based on their outlook for oil prices.

That’s a different situation than with OPEC. It is possible for OPEC to agree to collectively cut a million barrels a day of production (which would be about 2.5 percent of the group’s 2016 production), but virtually impossible (and in fact illegal) for U.S. producers to collude in the same fashion.

OPEC’s No-Win Strategy

The rationale OPEC gave when it decided to defend market share in 2014 was that it wasn’t fair that their production restraint was helping prop up the highest-cost producers (i.e., marginal shale oil producers).

Related: Are Combustion Engines Reaching Peak Demand?

This is a valid argument. In most businesses, high-cost producers tend to get squeezed out of the market. OPEC was, in fact, propping up these producers by restraining production and helping maintain elevated oil prices.

But fair or not, there were real consequences to OPEC’s strategy. They squeezed a few high-cost shale producers out of the market, but oil prices have dropped by more than 50 percent from the first half of 2014. Attempting to make things “fair,” in my opinion, was a Trillion Dollar Miscalculation on OPEC’s part.

The comments from the Secretary General may just mean that OPEC is hedging its bets. In its newly released Monthly Oil Market Report, the cartel has again raised its demand forecast for 2018. That is the third consecutive upward revision in OPEC’s 2018 demand forecast. The report even raised the possibility of a global supply deficit in 2018 unless oil output is increased.

Self-serving? Yes, but probably accurate. And U.S. shale oil producers stand to benefit.

By Robert Rapier

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:




Back to homepage

Trending Discussions


Leave a comment

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News