• 5 minutes Trump will capitulate on the trade war
  • 7 minutes China 2019 - Orwell was 35 years out
  • 12 minutes Glory to Hong Kong
  • 15 minutes ABC of Brexit, economy wise, where to find sites, links to articles ?
  • 4 mins Is Eating Meat Worse Than Burning Oil?
  • 3 hours Canada Election Deadlock?
  • 4 hours China & Coal: China's 2019 coal imports set to rise more than 10%: analysts
  • 6 mins Diplomatic immunity
  • 15 hours Clampdown on Chinese capital flight is shutting down their commercial construction in US
  • 23 hours Here's your favourite girl, Tom!
  • 1 day Peaceful demonstration in Hong Kong again thwarted by brutality of police
  • 2 hours Devaluing the Yuan
  • 3 hours Wonders of US Shale: US Shale Benefits: The U.S. leads global petroleum and natural gas production with record growth in 2018
  • 23 hours IMO 2020:
  • 14 hours Nigeria Demands $62B from Oil Majors
  • 1 day Deepwater GOM Project Claims Industry First
  • 12 hours Fareed Zakaria: Canary in the Coal Mine (U.S. Dollar Hegemony)
Alt Text

The End Of The Asian Oil Product Glut

Trafigura, one of the world’s…

Alt Text

Oil Discoveries Hit 70-Year Low

The last three years has…

Rory Johnston

Rory Johnston

Rory Johnston is a Master of Global Affairs student at the University of Toronto’s Munk School of Global Affairs where he focuses primarily on the…

More Info

Premium Content

New Study Finds Oil Sands Pollutants Underestimated by Official Estimates

The emission levels of some pollutants from the Athabasca oil sands may be higher than previous official estimates, according to researchers at the University of Toronto. The focus of the study, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), are listed as priority pollutants by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and known to exhibit carcinogenic and mutagenic properties.

“When dealing with chemicals that have such great potential to harm people and animals, it is absolutely vital that we truly understand how, and how much they are being released into the environment,” said Abha Parajulee, lead author of the paper.

Related article: Getting Around the US Crude Export Ban

Previous models for studying the oil sand’s pollutants focused solely on direct atmospheric emissions stemming from the bitumen extraction process and have found PAH emissions to be within acceptable limits. The paper, published Monday in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, argues that indirect emissions, such as evaporation from tailings ponds or wind erosion of on-site petroleum coke, are a greater contributor and have been underappreciated by regulators. These indirect emissions models better predicted PAH levels found in samples from the Athabasca oil sands region.

The Athabasca oil sands, the largest oil reserve in Alberta, contains 4,800 square kilometers of surface minable bitumen deposits. The bitumen is extracted from up to 100 meters below the surface and is processed using hot water. The residual fluids, which contain these PAHs, in addition to bitumen, sand, clay, and dissolved metals are then incarcerated in on-site tailings ponds. Further residual material, known as petroleum coke, is generated after the bitumen is upgraded and often remains on-site as well. This petroleum coke also contains heavier PAHs not released prior to upgrading.

Related article: Why Europe Won't See Canadian Crude Anytime Soon

According to the study, “estimated EIA emissions were insufficient to explain contaminant levels measured in the environment.” In continues, stating that “EIA estimates zero emissions of all PAHs except naphthalene from tailings areas, plant fugitives, and mine faces, an unrealistic estimation considering the oil sands extraction and upgrading process.” The authors conclude, “These inconsistencies suggest major alteration is required in the methodology used to estimate PAH emissions from different sources in environmental impact assessments.” These alterations, if undertaken, will surely increase the costs associated with regulatory compliance. This is bad news for oil companies operating in the oil sands that are already facing falling prices and shrinking profit margins.

While oilsands development is still in Canada’s national interest, it is essential to understand and account for externalities like PAHs. If regulations change to incorporate this new information, companies operating in Canada’s oil sands are going to need to innovate or perish.

By. Rory Johnston




Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage



Leave a comment

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play