• 3 minutes Nucelar Deal Is Dead? Iran Distances Itself Further From ND, Alarming Russia And France
  • 5 minutes Don Jr. Tweets name Ukraine Whistleblower, Eric Ciaramella. Worked for CIA during Obama Administration, Hold over to Trump National Security Counsel under Gen McCallister, more . . . .
  • 9 minutes Shale pioneer Chesepeak will file bankruptcy soon. FINALLY ! The consolidation begins
  • 12 minutes China's Blueprint For Global Power
  • 1 min Pioneer's Sheffield in Doghouse. Oil upset his bragging about Shale hurt prices. Now on campaign to lower expectations, prop up price.
  • 1 hour Tesla Launches Faster Third Generation Supercharger
  • 14 mins Passerby doused with flammable liquid and set on fire by peaceful protesters
  • 8 hours Who writes this stuff? "Crude Prices Swing Between Gains, Losses"
  • 10 hours EU has already lost the Trump vs. EU Trade War
  • 12 hours Joe Biden, his son Hunter Biden, Ukraine Oil & Gas exploration company Burisma, and 2020 U.S. election shenanigans
  • 13 hours Atty General Barr likely subpeona so called whistleblower and "leaker" Eric Ciaramella
  • 8 hours China's Renewables Boom Hits the Wall
  • 6 hours Climate Change Consensus Shifts in Wind, But Gas Is Still the Right Move
  • 16 hours Iran's Master Plan?
  • 15 hours Iran Finds New Oil Field With Over 50 Billion Barrels: Rouhani
  • 11 hours Does .001 of Atmosphere Control Earth's Climate?!

Breaking News:

Oil Rebounds On Surprise Crude Draw

Alt Text

This Key Gold Producer Sees Its Production Slump

Africa’s second gold producer Ghana…

Alt Text

Is This The Biggest Gold Deposit Ever Found In China?

China’s second biggest miner has…

Frik Els

Frik Els

Frik Els is editor for MINING.com in Vancouver, BC. Frik has been writing on business for the past 15 years covering the resource industry, investment, autos,…

More Info

Premium Content

Uncovering The Mystery Of South Africa’s Missing Gold Exports

According to a new study by the UN's Conference on Trade and Development, some commodity dependent developing countries "are losing as much as 67 percent of their exports worth billions of dollars to trade misinvoicing".

Trade misinvoicing – when export and import data between two countries do not align – is thought to be "one of the largest drivers of illicit financial flows from developing countries, so that the countries lose precious foreign exchange earnings, tax, and income that might otherwise be spent on development," according to the report.

UNCTAD's study uses data from up to two decades, covering exports of commodities such as cocoa, copper, gold, and oil from Chile, Cote d'Ivoire, Nigeria, South Africa, and Zambia.

Trade misinvoicing is thought to be one of the largest drivers of illicit financial flows from developing countries

"This research provides new detail on the magnitude of this issue, made even worse by the fact that some developing countries depend on just a handful of commodities for their health and education budgets," UNCTAD's Secretary-General, Mukhisa Kituyi, said:

"Importing countries and companies, which want to protect their reputations, should get ahead of the transparency game and partner with us to further research these issues."

The analysis shows patterns of trade misinvoicing on exports to China, Germany, Hong Kong (China), India, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, Spain, Switzerland, the UK and the U.S.:

• Between 2000 and 2014, underinvoicing of gold exports from South Africa amounted to $78.2 billion, or 67 percent of total gold exports. Trade with the leading partners exhibited the highest amounts: India ($40 billion), Germany ($18.4 billion), Italy ($15.5 billion), and the UK ($13.7 billion).

• Between 1996 and 2014, underinvoicing of oil exports from Nigeria to the United States was worth $69.8 billion, or 24.9 percent of all oil exports to the U.S.

• Between 1995 and 2014, Zambia recorded $28.9 billion of copper exports to Switzerland, more than half of all its copper exports, but these exports did not show up in Switzerland's books.

• Between 1990 and 2014, Chile recorded $16.0 billion of copper exports to the Netherlands, but these exports did not show up in the Netherlands' books.

• Between 2000 and 2014, underinvoicing of iron ore exports from South Africa to China was worth $3 billion. Related: Did Oil Kill The Dinosaurs?

This is another explanation of the Chile/Netherlands puzzle too as Holland is a center of LME warehouses

According to the report, gold exports from South Africa "is peculiar in that there is a perfect correlation between gold export underinvoicing and the volume of exports as reported by the country’s trading partners:"

"This suggests that export underinvoicing is not due to underreporting of the true value of gold exports, but rather to pure smuggling of gold out of the country. In other words, virtually all gold exported by South Africa leaves the country unreported."

Source: UNCTAD computation using UN Comtrade data

The headline numbers may be startling, but there are explanations for the discrepancies that do not relate to nefarious trade practices or tax dodging. Related: Why Oil Prices Might Not Rebound Until 2019

The FT quotes Christine Clough, of the U.S.-based group Global Financial Integrity, as saying the "suspicious results involving trading hubs such as Switzerland, particularly with regard to Zambian copper, were often because the commodities never went there":

“On paper most of the copper goes to Switzerland, but in reality the majority of it goes straight to buyers in other countries,” she said.

Writing in Forbes, Tim Worstall also point to the fact that the numbers – particularly in Zambia – may be skewed by the fact that commodity traders like Glencore, based in Switzerland, would deliver Zambia copper from its mines directly into London Metal Exchange warehouses around the world:

"Some of it will end up in storage at least for a time. But the storage will be in bonded, LME approved, warehouses. And bonded here means that it doesn’t turn up on the import statistics of a country. Because it hasn’t, in the legal sense, entered a country. This is another explanation of the Chile/Netherlands puzzle too as Holland is a center of LME warehouses."

By Frik Els via Mining.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:




Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage



Leave a comment
  • Lester on July 22 2016 said:
    It is misleading or deceptive to write about flows of commodities in terms of dollars. It leaves the reader without a clue to actual volumes of trade. Commodities are not defined and measured in dollars but weight and volume. In the real world no purchasing manager goes on the market saying "I want to buy $600 worth of gold or coffee or cacao. Especially today when a boatload of iron ore can be paid in SK wons or rands.

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play