• 3 minutes Marine based energy generation
  • 5 minutes "Saudi Armada heading to U.S.", "Dumping" is a WTO VIOLATION.
  • 8 minutes Why Trump Is Right to Re-Open the Economy
  • 12 minutes Which producers will shut in first?
  • 23 mins A small trial finds that hydroxychloroquine is not effective for treating coronavirus
  • 26 mins The GREAT OPEC+ Agreement
  • 3 hours US Shale Resilience: Oil Industry Experts Say Shale Will Rise Again
  • 10 hours Saudis to cut 4mm bbls. What a joke.
  • 39 mins Trumps Oil Industry....
  • 9 hours Saudi Arabia Is Buying Up European Oil Majors
  • 7 hours Trump will be holding back funds that were going to W.H.O. Good move
  • 5 hours Chinese Communist Party
  • 8 hours Russia's Rosneft Oil is screwed if they have to shut down production as a result of glut.
  • 34 mins Ten days ago Trump sent New York Hydroxychloroquine. Being administered to infected. Covid deaths dropped last few days. Fewer on ventilators. Hydroxychloroquine "Cause and Effect" ?
  • 10 hours Occidental hypocrisy
  • 5 hours Corona Price Tag
  • 13 hours Sharp real pure true hard working roughneck needing work..
Alt Text

Investors Return To Plowing Money Into Commodities

Commodities are trending once again…

Alt Text

Are We Really Facing A Battery Metal Shortage?

Electric car builder Tesla foresees…

John Daly

John Daly

Dr. John C.K. Daly is the chief analyst for Oilprice.com, Dr. Daly received his Ph.D. in 1986 from the School of Slavonic and East European…

More Info

Premium Content

Malaysian Environmentalists Lead Opposition to Rare Earth Processing Facility

With the price of rare earth elements due to China’s de facto monopoly now running at more than $100,000 per tons of unprocessed ore, it would seem that countries would be lining up to attempt to gain a piece of the action.

Many are, with operations extending from Estonia to Mongolia.

While the 17 elements, are not in themselves radioactive every global rare earth ore deposit is found amongst radioactive thorium deposits.

But the Third World model of attracting foreign investment, even in so rich a potential investment has aroused environmental concerns in Malaysia over the effects of such operations, throwing the classic model of Western dominated capitalist development into disarray.

On 9 October 1,000s of Malaysians demonstrated against plans to open a $230 million rare earth processing facility in the country’s eastern resort town in Kuantan, concerned about possible environmental damage.

Activist Tan Bun Teet said, “We deserve a healthy environment for our future generations. The government can't just build anything in the name of development.”

What is intriguing about the protest is that the rare earth elements (RREs) initially are to come from Australia. The Lynas Advanced Materials Plant is scheduled to start processing rare earths imported from Australia, to be used in high-tech products from iPods to Toyota Prius automobiles to U.S. cruise missiles.

Australian miner Lynas Corp. owners of the Lynas Advanced Materials Plant insists that the project would be beneficial, with Lynas Corp. executive chairman Nick Curtis stating that China’s 2010 decision to temporarily block shipments to Japan over a political dispute reinforced the importance of creating other supply alternatives.

If all goes according to plan then as many as 2,500 construction workers will soon be constructing the world’s largest rare earth metals refinery in Kuantan, the first rare earth ore processing plant to be built outside China in nearly 30 years. According to Lynas Corp., then the Kuantan facility will refine slightly radioactive RRE ore from the Australia’s Mount Weld after it is trucked to Australia’s Fremantle port for transportation by sea.

Malaysian Atomic Energy Licensing Board director general Raja Dato Abdul Aziz bin Raja Adnan, said that Malaysia approved the Lynas project only after an interagency review indicated the imported ore and subsequent waste would have low enough levels of radioactivity to be manageable and safe.

Malaysia’s environmentalist opposition to RRE mining is not new. In 1992 Malaysia’s RRE refinery, operated by Japan’s Mitsubishi Chemical, was shuttered, and the mine site is now one of Asia’s largest radioactive waste cleanup sites. Reviewing the experience Raja Adnan said, “We have learned we shouldn’t give anybody a free hand.”

During the 1990s Japan closed its RRE mines and Mitsubishi moved its refining operations to Malaysia to reprocess waste from old tin mines rich in RRE ore byproducts, which also contained extremely high levels of radioactive thorium.

Even one of the RREs’ prime markets, the U.S. Defense Department, has acknowledged its processing environmental legacy. In 2010 United States Army’s Foreign Military Studies Office analyst Cindy Hurst wrote in her “China’s Rare Earth Elements Industry: What Can the West Learn?” report , “Every ton of rare earth produced generates approximately 8.5kg of fluorine and 13 kg of dust… Using concentrated sulfuric acid high-temperature calcination to produce approximately one ton of REE generates 9 600 to 12 000 cubic meters of waste gas – containing dust concentrate, hydrofluoric acid, sulfur dioxide and sulfuric acid; approximately 75 cubic meters of acidic wastewater, and about one ton of radioactive waste residue.”

So, at the end of the day, the issues for Kuala Lumpur are simple – do the short-term profits of weakening China’s RRE monopoly of RRE production outweigh the long-term environmental consequences?

No clear answer has yet to emerge – but local opposition is mobilizing and the issue is increasingly whether Malaysia’s example will now be emulated by other developing governments interested in enhancing their bottom lines while being courted by Western mining concerns.

When does a purported good thing turn into something else?

By. John C.K. Daly of Oilprice.com


Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage






Leave a comment

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News