• 3 minutes Will Iron-Air batteries REALLY change things?
  • 7 minutes Natural gas mobility for heavy duty trucks
  • 11 minutes NordStream2
  • 9 hours U.S. Presidential Elections Status - Electoral Votes
  • 12 hours GREEN NEW DEAL = BLIZZARD OF LIES
  • 2 days Australia sues Neoen for lack of power from its Tesla battery
  • 19 hours Evergrande is going Belly Up.
  • 1 day Europeans and Americans are beginning to see the results of depending on renewables.
  • 14 hours Is China Rising or Falling? Has it Enraged the World and Lost its Way? How is their Economy Doing?
  • 14 hours Monday 9/13 - "High Natural Gas Prices Today Will Send U.S. Production Soaring Next Year" by Irina Slav
  • 7 hours Oil Price: does the security vacuum in the Middle East spook investors?
  • 6 hours Is the Republican Party going to perpetuate lies about the 2020 election and attempt to whitewash what happened on January 6th?
  • 1 day Ozone layer destruction driving global warming
  • 4 days Forecasts for Natural Gas
The Decisive Battle For Libya’s Oil Has Begun

The Decisive Battle For Libya’s Oil Has Begun

General Khalifa Haftar has announced…

Washington’s Libya Pivot Could Be A Game-Changer

Washington’s Libya Pivot Could Be A Game-Changer

US officials have met Libyan…

Irina Slav

Irina Slav

Irina is a writer for Oilprice.com with over a decade of experience writing on the oil and gas industry.

More Info

Premium Content

What Would A World Without OPEC Look Like?

A few years ago, as U.S. shale oil production soared towards 11 and then 12 million bpd, turning the country into the world’s largest oil producer, it was fashionable to start imagining that OPEC was becoming irrelevant. It took a pandemic to refute that argument; and now, OPEC is more relevant than ever. Yes, the cartel is riddled with internal rifts and disagreements, with much speculation about a breakup. And it’s fair enough to consider what the world would look like without OPEC. 

The short answer is, of course, that it would look quite different. With no oil cartel to control prices, every country with oil reserves would be free to exploit them at will, pumping to the maximum to take advantage of any opportunity to grow their market share—something that some OPEC members would very much like to be doing right now but cannot because of cartel obligations.

Without OPEC, oil prices would be a lot more volatile than they already are, even now, in some of the most uncertain times since oil began being used on a global scale. This, of course, would be boon for the new generation of day traders who are already having a disproportionately large effect on oil prices simply because of their numbers, with trading made as easy as playing Candy Crush. 

As Adam Rozencwajg, managing partner at Goehring and Rozencwajg, told Oilprice, “If OPEC were dissolved tomorrow there would undoubtedly be massive near-term price volatility.” However, Rozencwajg added that longer-term volatility was likely to suffer a lot less excess, comparing the 30-year historical volatility of crude to the same indicator for Henry Hub gas prices.

Related: JP Morgan: Don’t Expect A ‘Shock’ Transition In Energy Markets

Without OPEC, the security of the global oil supply would be a lot shakier than it is now, as well. One might argue that in the energy transition world, with oil losing relevance fast, this should not be of any serious concern; but in fact, oil is not losing its relevance so fast. It will be around for decades to come.

Yet, with OPEC members on the loose, free to produce as much oil as they want or can, there may be less incentive for oil companies to invest in new production to secure future supply, and this would increase supply insecurity over the long term, says Rozencwajg.

An Oxford Institute for Energy Studies’ report from last year looked at how the world would have looked if OPEC hadn’t been around between 1990 and 2018.

The analysis of data showed that global oil production would have been substantially higher with no cartel to keep it under control. It also suggested that oil supply shocks resulting from geopolitical events would have had a much greater impact on oil prices in a world without OPEC because in such a world everyone would be pumping at capacity, meaning they would have no spare capacity to tap and fill the gap in supply.

For instance, if there was no OPEC, when drone attacks on the Khurais field took 5.7 million bpd off Saudi oil production in 2019, there would have been a supply shock and prices would have jumped much higher than they actually jumped in the wake of the attacks. 

In fact, at the time, some analysts were forecasting $100 Brent prices; but there were also more sober minds that said there was no reason for oil to rise so high given that some OPEC+ members could increase production and that U.S. shale would do the rest. But if all OPEC+ members were pumping at capacity, it would have been up to U.S. shale to supply the difference and that would have taken a while.

As the Oxford Institute notes in its report, “Historical evidence shows that OPEC’s spare capacity has had a smoothing effect on global oil price movements, with prices under the counterfactual scenario exhibiting much sharper cycles both on the upside and the downside. For instance, in a world without OPEC spare capacity, the price would have risen by $110/b, from $51.6/b in 2010 to $161.7/b in 2012, compared to $30.7/b in the actual world.”

A world without OPEC would also likely see an even more disciplined oil industry. As one Wall Street Journal analysis from 2016—the previous oil price crash—suggested, when OPEC stopped trying to control prices and went for market share, prices slumped and investments were slashed. This is, of course, what happens during every oil crisis; but with no OPEC, this aspect of the crisis—stricter capital discipline—may have become the norm.

So, increased price volatility, stricter spending discipline in the industry leading to lower supply security in the future, and, as the Wall Street Journal noted in its analysis, an increased presence of hedge funds and other speculators in oil markets would be some of the post-OPEC features.

This would be a world with probably much more dramatic price swings and also a world of even deeper oil dependence for already oil-dependent economies, as these states would have a lot less motivation to diversify away from their principal source of budget revenues. For all the power OPEC has been resented for wielding on global oil markets, it seems that without it, things may have been worse.

By Irina Slav for Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:


Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage





Leave a comment
  • Stan Stan on August 30 2021 said:
    if there was no OPEC between 1990 and now, then average price for oil would be $10-15 for the period. But for instance, After drone attacks on the Khurais field the prices would had built to $50-60 at the short period. But with OPEC we have $50-60 as usual price for The whole period of 30 years!!! Just imagine how much the World overpayed last 3 decades and sponsored autocracies and dictatorships

    Any monopoly leads to higher prices
  • Mamdouh Salameh on August 30 2021 said:
    The short answer is that a world without OPEC at present will be chaotic, undisciplined, volatile and a sure route to the squandering of valuable proven reserves.

    Long-term, the picture will be different. There may not be a need for OPEC because the global oil market will be almost totally controlled by the Arab Gulf producers, Russia and Venezuela.

    However, let us start by dismissing once and for all the myth that OPEC is a cartel. A cartel is defined as an association of manufacturers and suppliers whose goal is to increase their collective profits by means of price fixing, limiting supply, preventing competition or other restrictive practices.

    How could OPEC be a cartel when it was founded as a counterweight against the previous “Seven Sisters” cartel of multinational oil companies which dominated every aspect of global oil through price fixing, limiting supplies and suppressing competition for the sole purpose of maximizing its profits. The main purpose behind the founding of OPEC was to give producers more control over their own oil.

    According to the 2021 BP Statistical Review of World Energy, OPEC accounted in 2020 for 34.7% of global oil production and 70.1% of the world’s proven oil reserves.

    OPEC has never once tried to fix a specific price nor has ever been able to achieve this goal. The fundamentals of the global oil market are the ones that have always determined the oil price helped occasionally by geopolitics. OPEC has no control on these fundamentals and therefore has no control on prices. For instance, OPEC was neither able to prevent prices from falling in the 1980s even after it adopted the production quota system in 1982 nor was it able to temper oil prices in 2008 when prices rocketed to $147 a barrel or stop the 2014 oil price crash.

    OPEC has emerged from the pandemic the most influential player in the global oil market. OPEC alone stood between a complete collapse of both the global oil demand and the global oil industry and the pandemic.

    The excessive pressure the environmental activists, the divestment campaigners and the IEA are exerting on oil supermajors to ditch fossil fuels will result in global oil supplies and resources controlled by only a few major players like the Arab Gulf oil producers, Russia and Venezuela who will be able to exact any price they wish.

    In such a situation, there will be no need for OPEC since there will be very few producers, namely, Iraq, Venezuela, Russia and Saudi Arabia each of which can produce to their heart’s content and impose whatever prices they need.

    On the whole, OPEC has been a force for good in almost 61 years of existence.

    Dr Mamdouh G Salameh
    International Oil Economist
    Visiting Professor of Energy Economics at ESCP Europe Business

Leave a comment




EXXON Mobil -0.35
Open57.81 Trading Vol.6.96M Previous Vol.241.7B
BUY 57.15
Sell 57.00
Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News