• 3 hours Getting out of oil .. now
  • 1 hour Surprise! Aramco Scraps International Listing Plans
  • 29 mins Bad News For The Climate: Coal Burning, And Carbon Emissions, Are On The Rise Again
  • 17 hours Too much or doable - $900 Billion Annual Investments Needed In Renewables By 2030
  • 3 mins This Will Be the Answer From China On U.S. Tariffs
  • 14 hours Elon Musk’s $2.6 Billion Tesla Challenge
  • 5 hours U.S. Judge To Question Big Oil On Climate Change
  • 2 hours The Facebook/Cambridge Analytica Scandal
  • 19 hours U.S. Arrests Iranian Over Alleged $115 Million Sanctions Evasion Scheme Involving Venezuelan Housing Project
  • 1 day "Rock star of science" - Stephen Hawking, Who unlocked The Secrets Of Space And Time, Dies at 76
  • 21 hours Bad seven days for Martin Shkreli
  • 5 hours Country With Biggest Oil Reserves Biggest Threat to World Economy
  • 1 day McDonald's Sets Greenhouse Gas Reduction Targets
  • 21 hours CERAweek Meeting
  • 18 hours Goldman Sachs Expects Tesla to Miss Model 3 Targets Again
  • 20 hours Nuclear Bomb = Nuclear War: Saudi Arabia Will Develop Nuclear Bomb If Iran Does

Breaking News:

Global Carbon Emissions Resume Rise

Alt Text

U.S. Shale’s Dirty Secret

Oil analysts are constantly discussing…

Alt Text

Shale Boom Creates New U.S. Oil Export Hub

Analysts at Wood MacKenzie expect…

Alt Text

Oil Prices Up As EIA Confirms Crude Draw

The Energy Information Administration reported…

Martin Tillier

Martin Tillier

More Info

Trending Discussions

OPEC Extension Leaves Markets Unimpressed


Those new to financial markets, and energy trading in particular, were probably somewhat puzzled by the price action in oil futures this week following the announcement by OPEC and some influential non-OPEC nations that they are extending the production cuts agreed last year for another nine months, until the end of Q1 2018. The logical reaction to that news would have been a spike in oil, but instead we saw a dramatic decline of around five percent once the announcement was made. That is easily explained in terms of trading dynamics, but one question remains. Is it a sign that we are heading lower or does it represent a good short-term buying opportunity?

(Click to enlarge)

“But the rumor, sell the fact” patterns like this are extremely common, and are the logical result of declaring the intent to enact a policy before actually doing so. Various OPEC members have made it clear over the last couple of weeks that an agreement was coming, so traders inevitably positioned themselves for that in advance of any actual announcement. Those statements, however, also set the rumor mill grinding and the whispers began to assume that more was coming. The market began to price in deeper cuts, which were never indicated, and when they did not come the extension became a negative for oil. All those traders that had taken long positions rushed to get out, and the ensuing results can be seen on the chart. That proves a point that I have often made here, that market positioning and dynamics going into news releases are more important than the news itself, but when the longer-term implications of the news are considered the selling looks likely to be overdone.

There is no doubt that OPEC, even with Russia and the other signatories to the agreement, are not the power that they once were. However, they still account for around half of the world’s current oil production, and there was some other, highly significant news that came out of the meeting. It appears that contrary to the expectations of many the new quotas have been largely adhered to. If that continues to be the case, the massive stockpiles of oil that were the real cause of the collapse in oil prices and have continued to put downward pressure on them will be reduced over time. Demand for oil is still increasing around the world as the long, slow recovery from the recession picks up pace and static supply from half of the world’s production capacity is therefore effectively a significant cut. Related: Is The U.S. Getting Left Behind In The Renewable Race?

Of course, conventional wisdom states that all that will happen is that production in North America and other non-OPEC areas will increase to compensate for that. The shale revolution has certainly unleashed the capacity for that to happen, but assuming that it will ignores the fundamental driver of output decisions in those areas…the market. The drop in WTI back below $50 is hardly likely to spur a rash of new wells, regardless of the OPEC action.

The fact is that, in general, shale oil is more expensive to produce than the conventionally drilled oil that comes from the Middle East and other OPEC countries. By cutting the supply of relatively cheap oil, therefore, the agreement takes away output that cannot easily be replaced in the U.S. or Canada. That doesn’t mean that we are headed back to three-digit oil prices any time soon, but it does make the low to mid 50s look like the logical place for WTI to be. On that basis, a recovery to those levels from here, rather than any further decline, is only logical.

By Martin Tillier for Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:

Back to homepage

Trending Discussions

Leave a comment
  • Josh Gregner on May 29 2017 said:
    You write: "By cutting the supply of relatively cheap oil, therefore, the agreement takes away output that cannot easily be replaced in the U.S. or Canada. [...] it does make the low to mid 50s look like the logical place for WTI to be. On that basis, a recovery to those levels from here, rather than any further decline, is only logical."

    How so? I would agree with your logic if the world would be at average levels of oil stocks. But we have the US selling half of its SPR, China curtailing its demand, more shale than ever flooding the market and the Deal Maker of OPEC being out of his job due to a government change. Oh, and most important to all: I don't see any indications for demand to increase.

    At least near-term I don't see any reason to be bullish.

    Longer term we will need to see how much hedging the shale producers have done to keep their oil supply coming to market. Worst case for OPEC, the shale guys' hedging could mean a prolonged period of cheap price is all OPEC gets while shale has their revenues in the bag and thus won't curtail production. And by the time US shale has dried-up in a few years global demand for oil may have spiked already.

Leave a comment

Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News