• 4 minutes Europeans and Americans are beginning to see the results of depending on renewables.
  • 7 minutes Is China Rising or Falling? Has it Enraged the World and Lost its Way? How is their Economy Doing?
  • 13 minutes NordStream2
  • 9 hours Monday 9/13 - "High Natural Gas Prices Today Will Send U.S. Production Soaring Next Year" by Irina Slav
  • 14 hours California to ban gasoline for lawn mowers, chain saws, leaf blowers, off road equipment, etc.
  • 18 hours "Here is The Hidden $150 Trillion Agenda Behind The "Crusade" Against Climate Change" - Zero Hedge re: Bank of America REPORT
  • 2 days An Indian Opinion on What is Going on in China
  • 2 days "A Very Predictable Global Energy Crisis" by Irina Slav --- MUST READ
  • 23 hours Nord Stream - US/German consultations
  • 2 days Can Technology Keep Coal Plants Alive and Well?
  • 3 days Two Good and Plausible Ideas about Saving Water and Redirecting it to Where it is Needed.
  • 3 days Succession Planning in Human Resources for Vaccinated Individuals in the Oil & Gas Industry
  • 5 days Perfect Energy Storm in Europe: turning our back on fossil fuels is easier said than done!
  • 2 days U.S. : Employers Can Buy Retirement Security for $2.64 an Hour
  • 2 days Storage of gas cylinders
Irina Slav

Irina Slav

Irina is a writer for Oilprice.com with over a decade of experience writing on the oil and gas industry.

More Info

Premium Content

Leading Fund Managers Say Aramco Is Significantly Overvalued

A day before Aramco is to announce the final price of the shares it will list on the Saudi stock exchange, the list of bad news for the company got longer. A survey among fund managers has shown that most of them believe that the company is overvalued by up to a third.

The survey was conducted among 31 asset managers holding assets of $3.8 trillion by Bernstein and reported by Fortune. Its conclusion supports what a number of observers have been saying for months now: that interest in Aramco shares among international investors is unlikely to be great because of too many uncertainties, including a lack of the transparency that international investors are accustomed to.

When Aramco last month announced a price range for its float, the mean in it gave the company a valuation of some $1.7 trillion. That’s $300 billion less than the original target valuation that Crown Prince Mohammed was after for Aramco. It also would mean IPO proceeds of $100 billion should 5 percent be floated.

However, the original plan has changed. Aramco will offer 1.5 percent of its stock next week, and it will offer them almost exclusively to Saudi investors. That’s after talk that Aramco could list more than the originally planned 5 percent, and up to 10 percent.

Things can change fast in the world of oil and they changed fast and for the worse for Aramco two months ago, when its oil field and a processing plant were struck with drones and missiles. The September 14 attacks added another potential problem to the list of problems they might have had with the Saudi company: security of supply.  Meanwhile, banks and analysts continued to argue how much Aramco was worth.

Goldman Sachs, one of the organizers of the IPO, has valued Aramco at even more than Riyadh: $2.3 trillion. Others, however, have valued it at just $1.2 trillion. Between these extremes, there is a host of other figures. None of them matter, however, if there is no one to buy the shares. Related: This Oil Major Just Pledged Net Zero Emissions By 2050

Fortunately for Aramco, there are a lot of people willing to buy its shares. Last week Aramco said it had attracted bids worth $44.3 billion by the deadline for retail investors to express interest in the listing. And that’s just retail investors. The company is also counting on local and regional institutional investors.

The Abu Dhabi Investment Authority—the country’s sovereign wealth fund—will reportedly buy shares worth $1 billion. The Kuwaiti sovereign wealth fund has, according to unnamed Reuters sources, also committed to $1 billion worth of shares. Other sources said both commitments were even higher, at $1.5-$2 billion each.

That, however, makes up for a tiny portion of the proceeds Aramco is eyeing. This means it will have to depend overwhelmingly on retail investors or urgently find institutional ones that are not too concerned about transparency. The latter is highly unlikely to happen just days from the official listing unless Riyadh is hiding a couple of investors up its sleeve. This means it will likely have to rely overwhelmingly on retail investors.

These are retail investors who are taking on loans to be able to afford the purchase of Aramco shares. As such, they are also investors who will start selling their shares the moment the price rises after the listing, if it does. And the moment the selloff starts will be the moment the share price will drop. Now that may be a good time for international investors to buy into Aramco. After all, it is still the biggest integrated oil company in the world with the biggest reserves, possibly the biggest production capacity, and a lot of downstream operations, too. What’s not to like?

By Irina Slav for Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:

Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment

EXXON Mobil -0.35
Open57.81 Trading Vol.6.96M Previous Vol.241.7B
BUY 57.15
Sell 57.00
Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News