• 15 hours Oil Prices Rise After API Reports Major Crude Draw
  • 16 hours Citgo President And 5 VPs Arrested On Embezzlement Charges
  • 16 hours Gazprom Speaks Out Against OPEC Production Cut Extension
  • 17 hours Statoil Looks To Lighter Oil To Boost Profitability
  • 18 hours Oil Billionaire Becomes Wind Energy’s Top Influencer
  • 19 hours Transneft Warns Urals Oil Quality Reaching Critical Levels
  • 20 hours Whitefish Energy Suspends Work In Puerto Rico
  • 21 hours U.S. Authorities Arrest Two On Major Energy Corruption Scheme
  • 1 day Thanksgiving Gas Prices At 3-Year High
  • 2 days Iraq’s Giant Majnoon Oilfield Attracts Attention Of Supermajors
  • 2 days South Iraq Oil Exports Close To Record High To Offset Kirkuk Drop
  • 2 days Iraqi Forces Find Mass Graves In Oil Wells Near Kirkuk
  • 2 days Chevron Joint Venture Signs $1.7B Oil, Gas Deal In Nigeria
  • 2 days Iraq Steps In To Offset Falling Venezuela Oil Production
  • 2 days ConocoPhillips Sets Price Ceiling For New Projects
  • 4 days Shell Oil Trading Head Steps Down After 29 Years
  • 5 days Higher Oil Prices Reduce North American Oil Bankruptcies
  • 5 days Statoil To Boost Exploration Drilling Offshore Norway In 2018
  • 5 days $1.6 Billion Canadian-US Hydropower Project Approved
  • 5 days Venezuela Officially In Default
  • 5 days Iran Prepares To Export LNG To Boost Trade Relations
  • 5 days Keystone Pipeline Leaks 5,000 Barrels Into Farmland
  • 5 days Saudi Oil Minister: Markets Will Not Rebalance By March
  • 5 days Obscure Dutch Firm Wins Venezuelan Oil Block As Debt Tensions Mount
  • 6 days Rosneft Announces Completion Of World’s Longest Well
  • 6 days Ecuador Won’t Ask Exemption From OPEC Oil Production Cuts
  • 6 days Norway’s $1 Trillion Wealth Fund Proposes To Ditch Oil Stocks
  • 6 days Ecuador Seeks To Clear Schlumberger Debt By End-November
  • 6 days Santos Admits It Rejected $7.2B Takeover Bid
  • 6 days U.S. Senate Panel Votes To Open Alaskan Refuge To Drilling
  • 6 days Africa’s Richest Woman Fired From Sonangol
  • 7 days Oil And Gas M&A Deal Appetite Highest Since 2013
  • 7 days Russian Hackers Target British Energy Industry
  • 7 days Venezuela Signs $3.15B Debt Restructuring Deal With Russia
  • 7 days DOJ: Protestors Interfering With Pipeline Construction Will Be Prosecuted
  • 7 days Lower Oil Prices Benefit European Refiners
  • 7 days World’s Biggest Private Equity Firm Raises $1 Billion To Invest In Oil
  • 8 days Oil Prices Tank After API Reports Strong Build In Crude Inventories
  • 8 days Iraq Oil Revenue Not Enough For Sustainable Development
  • 8 days Sudan In Talks With Foreign Oil Firms To Boost Crude Production
Alt Text

The U.S. Export Boom Goes Beyond Crude

While U.S. crude oil exports…

Alt Text

Oil Survives Bearish Backlash

Crude benchmarks posted steep losses…

Alt Text

Are Oil Markets Immune To U.S. Shale?

Oil prices have maintained their…

Peter Tertzakian

Peter Tertzakian

Peter is an economist, investment strategist, author and public speaker on issues vital to the future of energy. He has clocked over 30 years of…

More Info

How To Find The Big Winners In Energy Following The Oil Bust

Offshore Oil Rig

The charts look terrible. In the ruthless court of equity markets, the verdict is clear: The energy business – whether oil, gas, coal, solar, wind, nuclear, clean-tech or no-tech – is broadly guilty of delivering subpar returns to investors over the past five years.

So it’s no surprise that, “Why should I invest in energy?” is a routine question I hear.

Looking at baskets of companies for various primary energy groupings, I have to admit it’s difficult to argue with investors who shun putting dollars into companies that generate megajoules but destroy capital. I’m inclined to say, “You would have been better off investing in Antarctic real estate.”

Yet the question is not so much, “Why invest in energy?” but, “How to invest in energy?”

On the surface, it’s not obvious. While the broad S&P 500 Index has basically doubled since 2010, Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) that represent peer groups of publicly-traded energy companies have seen returns ranging from barely breaking-even to negative 77%. Solar stocks are at the bottom of the return spectrum, losing 77% on average since 2010. If you invested in coal stocks, your portfolio is down 67% over the same period. Oil and gas have been volatile, but have done comparably better at a 10% loss. Peer groups of wind and nuclear are at par. All are unimpressive when compared with the alternative of putting money in the S&P 500.

Superficially, the poor performance of energy equities is puzzling. An old finance adage says, “the market pays for growth.” Yet growth is not a problem in energy. Daily headlines trumpet fantastic deployment rates of renewables. Connecting the dots to companies, the rapid uptake of solar and wind power should make their equities mimic tech returns – more like Facebook and less like Remington Typewriters.

Oil growth remains robust too. New barrels are still being demanded at a gluttonous pace. The numbers should pinch anyone’s common senses: Places like India are putting 9,000 new gas guzzling vehicles on the road daily. In any other industry those numbers would make a financial advisor “back up the truck” for more stock.

Yet it’s folly to think that energy is like the tech industry where new products kill incumbents like a bad virus. Yes, music libraries and two-year-old mobile phones quickly become antiques in a market invaded with compelling new digital products, but energy doesn’t work that way. New capacity layers onto the stubborn old. Related: Oil Industry No Longer Discovering Oil, Only Growing Through M&A

When new megajoule-generating devices like wind turbines enter the market, the establishment doesn’t retreat politely. Drilling rigs, coal mines and nuclear reactors mobilize against the new entrants. It’s a full-on battle for market share that has already led to oversupply, price cuts and shrinking margins.

(Click to enlarge)

Rapid innovation is compounding the oversupply.

Take solar panels. The good news is that the costs have been cut in half in the past six years, due to the combination of greater conversion efficiencies and lower cost manufacturing. That means a dollar invested today results in twice as many shiny panels. Wind turbines are generating more power with larger blades and better aerodynamics. But who says innovation is limited to renewables? In North America the amount of oil and gas coming from each drilling rig has increased as much as seven-fold in the last half-dozen years, the gains have been powered by the combination of faster drilling times and higher production rates.

The world’s energy systems are in an ugly family feud to outproduce each other. Economists call it an “Energy Transition.” The tech guys call it, “Disruptive Innovation.” Environmentalists speak of “Decarbonization.” Call it what you want. In the world of business there are no euphemisms; it’s called things like, “Competition,” “Market Share Battle” and “Price War.”

Coal is fighting natural gas, and both are fighting renewables in generating electrons. Nuclear is in the fray too. Then there is the infighting, most pronounced in the oil fray, where low-cost competitors like Saudi Arabia are gunning to put their peers out of business.

Related: Long Term Consequences Of The Oil Price Crash

Falling prices. Thinning margins. Dribbling cash flow. Is it any surprise that energy equities are getting hammered?

But not all companies are bruising. Those that are reducing their costs as fast as, or faster than, prices are falling, are beating their peers. Their reward is superior market returns, in many cases beating the S&P 500.

There are big winners and big losers in each primary energy grouping. Important factors in fighting a market share battle are lowering costs; innovating products, improving process efficiency; and adapting to policy. Energy companies executing on those tactics are posting big wins. Conversely, enterprises that are laden with debt; too dependent on subsidies; laggards in technology; or sloppy with their costs are dragging their group’s average down like a supertanker’s anchor.

Market share battles serve an important purpose – they clean out inefficiencies and promote innovation. The war is far from over in energy. Battles for tomorrow’s megajoules are going to get more difficult for all players over the next few years until Charles Darwin’s ghost takes care of the weak by culling out high-cost, inefficient producers from each supplier group. When the cleanup ends, the energy ETFs should rise again.

Hyper competitive periods are a great time to invest in companies. But the how-to-invest strategy is not to indiscriminately buy low and sell high. Whichever energy system you favour, buy the best in the group and the odds are you will sell higher.

By Peter Tertzakian for Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:




Back to homepage


Leave a comment

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News