• 4 minutes Trump will meet with executives in the energy industry to discuss the impact of COVID-19
  • 8 minutes Charts of COVID-19 Fatality Rate by Age and Sex
  • 11 minutes Why Trump Is Right to Re-Open the Economy
  • 13 minutes Its going to be an oil bloodbath
  • 14 mins Ten days ago Trump sent New York Hydroxychloroquine. Being administered to infected. Covid deaths dropped last few days. Fewer on ventilators. Hydroxychloroquine "Cause and Effect" ?
  • 35 mins US Shale Resilience: Oil Industry Experts Say Shale Will Rise Again
  • 11 mins Russia's Rosneft Oil is screwed if they have to shut down production as a result of glut.
  • 13 hours Mr
  • 22 hours While China was covering up Covid-19 it went on an international buying spree for ventilators and masks. From Jan 7th until the end of February China bought 2.2 Billion masks !
  • 2 hours ‘If it saves a life’: Power cut to 1.5 million Californians
  • 11 hours Free market or Freeloading off the work of others?
  • 1 day What If ‘We’d Adopted A More Conventional Response To This Epidemic?’
  • 1 day How to Create a Pandemic
  • 12 hours Marine based energy generation
  • 17 hours Which producers will shut in first?
  • 1 day Real Death Toll In CCP Virus May Be 12X Official Toll

Breaking News:

WTI Slides On Huge Crude Inventory Build

Alt Text

Oil Industry Joins The Fight Against Coronavirus

The coronavirus has forced businesses…

Alt Text

Renewables Boomed In 2019, But This Year May Be Different

Renewable energy projects constituted three-quarters…

Gary Hunt

Gary Hunt

Gary Hunt is President, Scalable Growth Strategy Advisors, an independent energy technology and information services adviser and a partner in Tech & Creative Labs, a…

More Info

Premium Content

Dysfunction and Cynicism Rule in Environmental Regulation

The US Environmental Protection Agency is expected to publish new proposed rules setting air quality standards for soot this week under terms of a tentative settlement agreement reached with eleven states that sued EPA for NOT acting to promulgate rules for fine particulate matter under the Clean Air Act.

If you are curious about the air quality where you live you can visit the EPA Air Now website and check out the daily readings being reported.  For most of us the map looks green (green is good remember) and the urban areas tend to shade yellow (moderate) to orange (unhealthy for sensitive groups).  This is a testament to good work that US EPA has done over the years to clean up our air and water and the broad public support there is for such action.

By now you are wondering why I am praising the US EPA?  I spend so much time writing about the torture of endless regulatory uncertainty and the unintended costs and consequences of a regulatory regime that fails to balance the costs of new regulation with the benefits and the public interest.   US EPA is often called the poster child for out of control regulatory policies.  But these eleven states represented by their attorneys general are classic examples of the dysfunction and cynicism at work today in the regulatory process.

So listen up.

The proposed soot regulation of fine particulate matter is a classic case of the hijacking of the regulatory process by environmental advocates, pandering attorneys general and other interveners with no economic stake in the matter (except they get paid by endlessly suing and coercing settlements out of companies and government entities eager to avoid the ‘perp walk’ of being labelled a polluter. In the case of fine particulate matter the US EPA has focused on the problems as far back at 2005.  In 2007 US EPA finalized the 2.5 ppm Clean Air Fine Particle Implementation Rule setting requirements for state plans to meet the 1997 national air quality standards for fine particle pollution.

But in February 2011 eleven states including New York, California, Connecticut, Delaware, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Mexico, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont and Washington sued US EPA to step up the pace for new soot rules. This, of course, provided each state Attorney General will endless opportunities to generate press stories wrapping themselves in the green flag.

Here is an example:

“Clean air is a public right, and standards that protect it are a necessity,” Eric T. Schneiderman, New York State’s attorney general, said in a statement. “Every day, air pollution from soot risks the health of more than one-third of Americans, including our most vulnerable –- children, the elderly and the sick. These risks are simply unacceptable.”

Really?   Take a look at the map of airnow.gov, the daily air quality reports again.  Does this look like the sky is falling on air quality that the New York AG paints in his press release?

Working at the US EPA must be torture.  Putting up with an endless stream of politicians looking to score points and generate headlines.  Environmental interveners in regulatory proceedings or litigators are hijacking the agencies (plural because this is a problem with all regulation not just at US EPA) resources and driving its agenda usually to the outer limits of reasonableness in pursuit of their own political or environmental agenda.

What is being left out is the public interest.  What is being ignored is common sense.  What is missing is BALANCE between the need for reasonable regulations to protect the public interest and assure our environmental quality and the equally important public interest in economic growth, job creation, making an environment for business predictability and certainty so that capital will be invested, better technology will be used, and our enviable pace of environmental quality improvement can be sustained.

What we’re doing now in allowing the regulatory process to be hijacked is not sustainable.

By. Gary L Hunt


Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage






Leave a comment
  • Enviro Equipment Blog on June 18 2012 said:
    First, the EPA is suggesting lowering the levels of so-called particles by just over 13% and even then they're expected to have six months of debate on its merits before making a final ruling on the proposal. I hardly consider this to the dysfunction and cynicism at its worst.

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News