• 5 minutes Global Economy-Bad Days Are coming
  • 8 minutes IT IS FINISHED. OPEC Victorious
  • 14 minutes Venezuela continues to sink in misery
  • 18 minutes U.S. Senate Advances Resolution To End Military Support For Saudis In Yemen
  • 2 hours Paris Is Burning Over Climate Change Taxes -- Is America Next?
  • 3 hours $867 billion farm bill passed
  • 8 mins Rage Without Proof: Maduro Accuses U.S. Official Of Plotting Venezuela Invasion
  • 12 hours OPEC Cuts Deep to Save Cartel
  • 6 mins Has Global Peak Diesel Arrived?
  • 3 hours IEA Sees Global Oil Supply Tightening More Quickly In 2019
  • 8 hours Sleeping Hydrocarbon Giant
  • 4 hours USGS Announces Largest Continuous Oil Assessment in Texas and New Mexico
  • 4 hours How High Can Oil Prices Rise? (Part 2 of my previous thread)
  • 10 hours Air-to-Fuels Energy and Cost Calculation
  • 10 hours What will the future hold for nations dependent on high oil prices.
  • 13 hours And the War on LNG is Now On
  • 8 hours Could Tesla Buy GM?
Alt Text

Oil Majors Cautious But Upbeat About 2019

Oil majors ConocoPhilips and Hess…

Alt Text

Australians Create Battery From Waste

Australian battery makers have succeeded…

Alt Text

Will Self-Driving Cars Ever Be Safe Enough?

Collisions involving self-driving cars are…

Ed Dolan

Ed Dolan

Edwin G. Dolan holds a Ph.D. in economics from Yale University. Early in his career, he was a member of the economics faculty at Dartmouth…

More Info

Trending Discussions

Does Charging for Electricity Provide an Effective Incentive for Conservation?

Economists can't always conduct controlled experiments to test hypotheses about public policy, but sometimes experiments occur naturally. New York City electric rates provide an example. About 1.75 million New York apartments have metered electricity, paying an average of 21 cents per kilowatt hour, among the highest rates in the nation. At the same time, about 250,000 older apartments have unlimited, unmetered electric power included in the rent. A recent article by Sam Dolnick in The New York Times compares electricity use in the two types of apartments. The NYC experiment can be used to test three a priori hypotheses about the elasticity of demand for electricity.

First, demand might be completely inelastic. Although this hypothesis would not appeal to most economists, it reflects a line of argument often found in popular discussions. How many times have you heard someone say something like this: "Raising electric rates wouldn't help conservation. Rich people can afford to use as much as they want regardless of the price. And poor people would still need electricity to live, so raising the price would just make them poorer."

Second,  demand might have constant elasticity. Because of their convenient mathematical form, constant elasticity curves are often used in empirical studies. Because they never intersect the axes, they imply that the quantity demanded would be unlimited if the price fell to zero.

Third, the demand curve might be linear. Textbooks are full of linear demand curves. Some people joke that is because lazy authors find them easier to draw. A linear demand curve implies that demand is finite even when the good is free.

Observations from the New York experiment shed light on these hypotheses. Demand is greater in unmetered apartments. Some people do use electricity very wastefully, for example, running their air conditioners full blast while they are at work so that their cats will be comfortable. Still, demand does not increase without limit. Electric use is only about 30 percent higher in unmetered apartments than metered ones.

Taken together, these observations allow us to reject the hypotheses of perfect inelasticity and constant elasticity. Looks like the lazy old linear demand curve provides the best fit after all. And yes, skeptic, charging for electricity does provide an effective incentive for conservation.

By. Ed Dolan

"This post originally appeared on Ed Dolan's Econ Blog at Economonitor.com, and is reprinted here with permission."




Back to homepage

Trending Discussions


Leave a comment

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News