• 3 minutes e-car sales collapse
  • 6 minutes America Is Exceptional in Its Political Divide
  • 11 minutes Perovskites, a ‘dirt cheap’ alternative to silicon, just got a lot more efficient
  • 4 days The United States produced more crude oil than any nation, at any time.
  • 3 days How Far Have We Really Gotten With Alternative Energy
  • 2 days Bad news for e-cars keeps coming
  • 3 days China deletes leaked stats showing plunging birth rate for 2023
  • 5 days The European Union is exceptional in its political divide. Examples are apparent in Hungary, Slovakia, Sweden, Netherlands, Belarus, Ireland, etc.
Cyril Widdershoven

Cyril Widdershoven

Dr. Cyril Widdershoven is a long-time observer of the global energy market. Presently he works as a Senior Researcher at Hill Tower Resource Advisors. Next…

More Info

Premium Content

Are Algorithms To Blame For Europe’s Natural Gas Crisis?

  • While it appears that Russia has been refusing to send extra natural gas to Europe during the current shortage, the continents energy crisis may have been caused by something else
  • Putin has long understood the significance of the liberalization of European gas markets, and algorithmic trading may have played a part in soaring prices
  • If Russia was indeed able to manipulate prices higher by using ‘paper volumes’, then the security of Europe’s broader energy market will have to be looked at

The continuing European energy market crunch is still making headlines. The main culprit, according to media and politicians, is Russia, as it is refusing to increase its gas deliveries to the market. When looking at market fundamentals, it certainly appears that Russia is partly responsible for the energy shortage, but there is a major underlying issue that is not being covered. Putin has weaponized the energy markets by using an intricate web of trading instruments, media attention, and supply-side control. Russia has been playing pipeline politics with oil via the OPEC+ agreement and with natural gas via its control of European markets. After warning European leaders several times in recent years, Putin now seems to have used the financialization of energy markets, aka paper values and not volumes, to his advantage. 

In recent years, Putin has been looking to use the changing European gas market to his advantage. Europe’s liberalization of its domestic gas markets combined with a full focus on spot market options, such as TTF and others, removed long-term contracts as a primary source. Long-term contracts, based on oil-price indexed contracts, were seen as the main constraint to liberalization and lower price settings. This change to spot contracts was due to Europe’s desire to become less import-dependent on Russian natural gas while opening up to international LNG options. For the first years, this change worked well, as prices went down and diversification, at least on paper, increased. 

More recently, however, the situation changed dramatically and Russia once again gained the upper hand. While European politicians were focusing on Ukrainian gas pipelines or Nordstream 2, the internal function of the European gas market was largely ignored. In reality, the liberalization of gas markets, especially in Europe, put more power into the hands of independent gas trading groups, including Gazprom. 

Without pushing for a direct confrontation, Russia was able to play with market fundamentals. The push by European nations to go all-out on renewables, discarding the idea of gas as the transition fuel of choice, threatened Russia’s future. Putin and his supporters warned Europe that there could be major repercussions for that move, but the message fell on deaf ears in Brussels. 

It seems that Europe’s politicians failed to understand a major threat in modern international gas trading, namely the role of new technology and algorithms. Putin’s advisors clearly understood both the positive and negative options associated with putting gas market futures and deals in the hands of algorithm-based systems. 

An in-depth analysis of current gas markets, including EU and UK gas storage volumes, is partly clouding the overall real situation. There is doubt that current gas storage volumes are lower than before, however, no real attention has been given to the fact that one of the main drivers behind the current energy crunch and extremely high prices, which are to the advantage of Putin, are caused by 3rd party moves. 


Europe Natural Gas Storage

In recent months, financial players and traders have been committing to extreme high hedging and speculative positions, not only in natural gas markets but also in electricity markets. Analysis of the commitments of traders report ICE Europe data on TTF futures trading shows that speculation has been a major driver behind the current price spikes and shortages. Putin has been able to use the system of natural gas and electricity markets to his own advantage, aka weaponizing his own energy trade position in the market.

Related: A Very Predictable Global Energy Crisis

As a trader stated, while Europe wanted its own energy exchange (EEX) to hold market power, the reality is that the EEX is not even close to ICE Endex and ICE Europe. Taking into account US CME/NYMEX and ICE US Energy Division, EEX is being dwarfed when looking at energy derivatives trading. If EEX is even analyzed, it is clear that the same players of other exchanges are in place. The EEX main shareholder is Deutsche Börse Group with 75% of the shares, followed by Edison S.p.A., Enel Global Trading S.p.A. (Italy), and 3 Austrian organizations. Deutsche Börse Group's shareholders are 90% institutional shareholders, of which 36% are from North America and 25% are from Great Britain. If you now analyze EEX, it becomes clear that it is directly linked to major Russian traders. Of the 424 participants, the main heavyweights include Gazprom Austria GmbH, Gazprom Marketing & Trading Limited, Gazprom Marketing & Trading Switzerland AG, and Novatek Gas & Power GmbH. The EEX also holds key financial organizations with their own spot and derivatives arms, such as BofA Securities Europe SA, Citadel Energy Investments, Citigroup Global Markets, Goldman Sachs Bank Europe SE, Goldman Sachs International, J.P. Morgan, Mizuho Securities USA, Morgan Stanley, Societe Generale International, etc. When it comes to energy trading in Europe, international financial players are holding all the cards and are able to influence (or manipulate) the market. 

Current price spikes are not abnormal if it is understood that all financial players have been betting on higher prices since the beginning of this year. Goldman Sachs pitched a commodities “supercycle” in April 2021, JPMorgan followed a bit later. All other major financials followed suit very soon after, leading to a legal but pushy energy price spike expectation. These forecasts were made even at times when physical markets, oil especially, did not demonstrate crude oil shortages. As several analysts repeatedly stated, US markets don’t need a lot of crude oil storage. Fluctuations in the USA were seasonable. At the same time, storage reports in Fujairah, Singapore, and Japan, indicated “normal” physical storage situations. 

Just after Gazprom’s condensate processing facility in Siberia was destroyed, the crude oil hysteria jumped to natural gas. Crisis reports started to emerge in the market. These reports seem to have been very well understood by Russian parties, as Gazprom decided to put pressure on the physical gas market, expecting financial markets to move very soon after. International traders, such as Vital, Glencore, and Trafigura, were looking at that time at extreme risks in their portfolios, as there were large short positions on gas and power in the financial markets. Reports emerged last week that Gunvor, the largest independent LNG trader, is back in the debt markets, for the 1st time since 2013. Zerohedge stated that Gunvor is facing massive margin calls as the global natural gas arb explodes. Possible casualties are ABNAmro, Credit Agricole, Rabobank, SG, Natixis, ING, and Unicredit.  The site reports also that the margin calls are between $3.6B and $6.1B in the coming months for a company with a $2.5B net equity. 

ICE index

Natural Gas COT Summary

Russian Natural Gas Flows

The natural gas crunch in Europe may well be a self-made issue. To increase the influence of financial markets over energy markets is to increase the risk of volatility. With a huge uncontrolled OTC market in place, with immense volumes of financials swaps being traded, with re-hedging by swap-dealers, and nearly 70% of trading volume coming from algorithmic trading, the threat to natural gas markets is clear.


Related: Is America Doomed To Replicate Europe’s Energy Crisis?

It is possible that Russia combined its potential physical gas market manipulation with its ability to influence financial markets. It is unclear which came first, but a combination of both, clearly not understood by unprepared European politicians, has given Russia a potent geopolitical weapon. By understanding the fundamentals of both sides, extreme energy price spikes are easy to realize. By understanding that algorithms now control the financial market and that the natural gas market is no longer focused on physical trades but on paper trading, Russia is able to move markets. Most algorithms of traders are linked to certain market keywords, events, or price level red lines. They act automatically, in principle to prevent spikes or huge losses on respective futures holdings. In the current European energy crunch, Russia seems to have been able to tweak the system to its own advantage. In the past, Putin’s response to a new energy market was, “if Europe wants a liberalized open energy market, let’s have it”. Now, he is all too happy to point out that “Europe’s current energy crunch is its own doing, now deal with your own strategy”. Claims by the IEA that Russia is unable to provide more natural gas have not be proven. Russia is currently using all the instruments at its disposal to prove that Russia’s energy weapon is ready and armed. 

In the coming months, the weaponization threat of a fully financialized energy market needs to be assessed, and measures to prevent a repeat of current events should be taken. Handing over total control of energy prices and volume trades to paper, based on algorithms, is clearly a problem that needs to be resolved.

By Cyril Widdershoven for Oiprice.com

More Top Reads from Oilprice.com:

Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage

Leave a comment
  • Kay Uwe Boehm on October 11 2021 said:
    There.is no real gas supply problem in europe with huge has storage reserves in old gas fields, 36 LNG terminals, new pipeline to aserbaidschan open not already new Nordstream II to russia still in testing phase but old pipelines.
    About 50% gas in FRG from norway 25% in EU with production at top level in future much gas from turkey, greece etc. israel already LNG producer etc.
  • Robert Berke on October 11 2021 said:
    Lots of speculation over what could have occurred with no evidence of what really occurred.
  • One Second on October 12 2021 said:
    What all the fossil fuel people including Putin fail to understand is that this will backfire massively. In Germany right know the big industrial players are calling on the future government to massively expand the annual deployment of renewables which is perfectly in line with what the environmentalists fought for all along. Combine this with a stable 90 % of the population being in favour of the energy transition and everything but a massively increased renewable deployment in the coming years in Germany would be a major surprise.
    The consensus in Europe always was that it would be very unwise from Russia to use its energy supplies as a weapon. The argument always was that Russia wouldn't do that so that there was nothing to worry and gas was a save bet as a transition fuel. Putin has now shot that argument dead. Therefore there is no more argument for gas in Europe now, but an overwhelming argument for getting the energy transition to 100 % renewables done as quickly as possible, which also gets cheaper by the day especially in comparison. Thanks Putin!

Leave a comment

EXXON Mobil -0.35
Open57.81 Trading Vol.6.96M Previous Vol.241.7B
BUY 57.15
Sell 57.00
Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News