• 5 minutes China Faces Economic Collapse
  • 8 minutes ZeroHedge: Oil And Gas Bankruptcies To Accelerate As $137 Billion Debt Matures Over Next Two Years
  • 11 minutes Trump Will Win In 2020
  • 14 minutes Oil Production Growth In U.S. Grinds To A Halt
  • 3 hours The Belt & Road Initiative: A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing?
  • 2 hours Drone attacks cause fire at two Saudi Aramco facilities, blaze now under control
  • 8 hours How OPEC and OECD play their role in setting oil price in light of Iranian oil sanction ?? Does the world agree with Iran's oil sanctions ???
  • 6 hours Cost of oil
  • 51 mins Democrats and Gun Views
  • 15 hours Swedish Behavioral Scientist Suggests Eating Humans to ‘Save the Planet’ from Climate Change. What could possibly go wrong?
  • 16 hours Trump Orders Biofuel Boost
  • 11 hours Iran says tanker oil sold at sea, buyer sets destination
  • 1 hour US and China are already in a full economic war and this battle for global hegemony is a little bit frightening
  • 19 hours Used Thin Film Solar Panels at 15 Cents per Watt
  • 19 hours Green New Deal Preview in Texas Town
  • 16 hours “Who’s going to bail out the Central Banks?”
  • 43 mins Iran in the world market
Alt Text

China Helps Venezuela Boost Oil Production

China has financed the construction…

Alt Text

Can Argentina's Shale Boom Survive?

Argentina’s shale boom is falling…

Alt Text

Tighter Inventories Give Oil Markets Hope

Oil traders continue to look…

Gail Tverberg

Gail Tverberg

Gail Tverberg is a writer and speaker about energy issues. She is especially known for her work with financial issues associated with peak oil. Prior…

More Info

Premium Content

Oil Industry Still Coming Under Fire

Bashing the oil industry seems to be popular. The most recent example is the New York Times’ editorial They haven’t learned.

I don’t think any industry is perfect, but I also have a hard time seeing that any industry should be singled out for uniquely harsh treatment. Things are going to go wrong whenever human decisions are involved, so we need to figure out ways to make systems as idiot-proof as possible.

With respect to blow-outs, a Joint Industry Task Force was put together shortly after the Deepwater Horizon blow out to take steps very quickly that would reduce the likelihood of blowouts and improve the possibility of control if such blowouts do take place. I don’t think that it is possible to completely eliminate blowout risk, but steps such as this task force is taking would seem to go a long ways. Stopping work elsewhere doesn’t really help the situation.

One of the big issues with oil is our tremendous need for it, just to keep current systems operating. It is fashionable to think that wind, or solar PV, or biofuels can somehow substitute for oil. Wind and solar PV don’t substitute for oil. What they do is create intermittent electricity, which is not at all the same. Biofuels don’t scale well, and unless they are “chemically equivalent” tend to cause problems in the machinery that use them, if they are added as more than a small percentage of the fuel mix.

Another big issue with oil is its cost, especially when it is imported from around the world. There is a huge advantage in producing oil in this country if we can–in terms of local jobs, and in terms of keeping the funds in our own economy.

Oil from abroad may not always be as available as everyone expects, either. The New York Times editorial talks about the US controlling only 3% of the world’s known reserves. In fact, OPEC reserves used in calculating the 3% ratio seem to be greatly overstated, so the US likely does control far more than 3% of the world’s productive capacity. But a lot of folks have stuck their heads in the sand, thinking that OPEC has a great deal more productive capacity than it likely really has. Overstated OPEC oil reserves are an issue the New York Times should be bringing to its readers, but it has not.

Oil production in the US is not something that one can just turn on and off at will. People who work in the industry depend on stable job situations. If trained workers in the oil industry can’t find jobs in the oil industry, they will move on to other industries, where they can find jobs. If one stops and restarts drilling, the danger is that there will be fewer workers with experience later, making the risk of accidents higher.

Government oversight of the oil industry (and probably a lot of other industries) has not been very good. It is hard to see how this is going to change in the near future, because it takes a lot of training to understand appropriate procedures, and this really can only be learned by working in the industry. It may be that the oil industry itself will need to be involved with more aspects of regulation, and the government will need to play a more limited role. But halting drilling while all of this is sorted out doesn’t really help the result.

It seems to me that business can and should go on as usual, while all of the details of regulation and preventing future blowouts is sorted out. The industry had a good safety record prior to the Deepwater Horizon blowout, and it is taking steps now to prevent future blowouts. After seeing the high price that BP is having to pay for its spill, companies clearly have a financial incentive to make certain that they are operating safely. So it seems to me that the harsh position of the New York Times is unnecessary.

By. Gail Tverberg

Gail Tverberg is a writer and speaker about energy issues. She is especially known for her work with financial issues associated with peak oil. Prior to getting involved with energy issues, Ms. Tverberg worked as an actuarial consultant. This work involved performing insurance-related analyses and forecasts. Her personal blog is ourfiniteworld.com. She is also an editor of The Oil Drum.




Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage



Leave a comment
  • Anonymous on January 01 2011 said:
    In my humble opinion the oil industry has taken an unjustified bashing. I have no love for that industry, because I seem to remember applying for a job with one of the majors, and being turned down, but I believe that they have done a good job for the citizebs if the Big PX over the years. The problem is that they are going to have to take the bitter with the sweet, and the bitter is that oil is scarce. And for reasons that I will not go into here, it will remain that way.

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play