• 4 minutes Trump will meet with executives in the energy industry to discuss the impact of COVID-19
  • 8 minutes Charts of COVID-19 Fatality Rate by Age and Sex
  • 11 minutes Why Trump Is Right to Re-Open the Economy
  • 13 minutes Its going to be an oil bloodbath
  • 14 mins Ten days ago Trump sent New York Hydroxychloroquine. Being administered to infected. Covid deaths dropped last few days. Fewer on ventilators. Hydroxychloroquine "Cause and Effect" ?
  • 35 mins US Shale Resilience: Oil Industry Experts Say Shale Will Rise Again
  • 11 mins Russia's Rosneft Oil is screwed if they have to shut down production as a result of glut.
  • 13 hours Mr
  • 22 hours While China was covering up Covid-19 it went on an international buying spree for ventilators and masks. From Jan 7th until the end of February China bought 2.2 Billion masks !
  • 2 hours ‘If it saves a life’: Power cut to 1.5 million Californians
  • 11 hours Free market or Freeloading off the work of others?
  • 1 day What If ‘We’d Adopted A More Conventional Response To This Epidemic?’
  • 1 day How to Create a Pandemic
  • 12 hours Marine based energy generation
  • 17 hours Which producers will shut in first?
  • 1 day Real Death Toll In CCP Virus May Be 12X Official Toll

Breaking News:

WTI Slides On Huge Crude Inventory Build

Alt Text

Are We Really Facing A Battery Metal Shortage?

Electric car builder Tesla foresees…

Alt Text

World's Second Largest Lithium Miner Is Reeling From Low Prices

The world’s second largest lithium…

Alt Text

Chinese Rare Earth Exports Tumble As Trade War Accelerates

China, the world’s largest producer…

Ed Dolan

Ed Dolan

Edwin G. Dolan holds a Ph.D. in economics from Yale University. Early in his career, he was a member of the economics faculty at Dartmouth…

More Info

Premium Content

How China Threw Its Rare Earths Monopoly Away

Rare earth elements (REEs) are a group of seventeen elements with exotic names like neodymium and yttrium that are key ingredients in many high-tech products, many important for national defense. Imagine the consternation of Western officials when they woke up one morning in September 2010 to learn that China held a near-monopoly in the production of these vital materials. In retaliation for the collision of a Chinese fishing boat with a Japanese Coast Guard vessel near a group of disputed islands in the East China Sea, China threatened an embargo. Prices of REEs soared.

How did China become the world’s leading producer of REEs? Did the 97 percent market share it held in 2010 represent a true natural monopoly? At the time, I wrote that its hold on the market was more fragile than it appeared. The erosion of China’s dominance of REEs holds important lessons for all supposed natural monopolies.

The first clue should have been that rare elements are not really rare. All seventeen rare earth elements are more abundant in the earth’s crust than gold, and some of them are as abundant as lead. The thing that makes them hard to mine is the fact that they do not occur in highly concentrated deposits like gold and lead. Even the best REE ores have very low concentrations. On the other hand, such ores exist widely throughout the world. Until the 1960s, India, Brazil, and South Africa were the leading producers. From the 1960s to the 1990s, the Mountain Pass Mine in California was the biggest source. China began to dominate REE production only in the late 1990s. Related: Some Good News From This War-Torn Nation’s Oil Industry

Ownership of natural resources turned out to be only one factor that led to China’s big share of the REE market. Yes, it had good ore deposits, but not uniquely good. It also had low labor costs, which helped China’s REE mines just as they help its toy factories. A further consideration may have been most important of all: Mining of REEs can produce very nasty waste products. For years, Chinese authorities were willing to turn a blind eye to environmental devastation caused by primitive, often illegal, but low-cost small-scale mines. Meanwhile, environmental problems were a major factor leading to the shutdown of the Mountain Pass Mine. Following a big spill of radioactive waste, U.S. authorities demanded new environmental safeguards. Already facing low-cost Chinese competition, the mine closed rather than undertake the needed investments.

Still, even if China never had a true natural monopoly, it did have considerable short-run market power. In the short run, supply of REEs is much less elastic than in the long run. Any short run increase in supply can only come from mines that are already open or, to a very limited extent, come from “urban mining”—that is, recycling of REEs from scrapped computers and the like. Related: 3 Ways Oil Companies Can Survive Low Prices

Short-run demand is also inelastic. Once high-tech production lines are set up to produce hybrid cars or computer hard drives using REE-dependent technologies, it is not possible just to substitute nickel for the neodymium in a magnet and expect it still to do its job.

In the long run, though, elasticity of both supply and demand turned out to be much higher, as Eugene Gholz of the University of Texas notes in a recent report from the Council on Foreign Relations. After the 2010 run-up in REE prices, the U.S. mining company Molycorp quickly obtained a permit to reopen California’s Mountain Pass Mine, using newer, cleaner, and lower-cost technology. By 2013, it was filling market orders. Australia’s Lynas Corporation began developing an operation in Malaysia at about the same time. Other ventures in Kazakstan, South Africa, and Canada soon followed. Related: Who Is The Biggest Player In Energy?

On the demand side, REEs turned out to be not quite as irreplaceable in high-tech products as it seemed at first. At least in many cases, producers use REE-dependent technologies not because they are the only way to do something but because they are a good way to do it given reasonable prices and reliable availability of the raw materials. Japanese, Korean, and U.S. companies soon began to develop alternative technologies like magnets that used only a fraction of the amount of the REE dysprosium as they had used before.

The bottom line: China still has a large market share—around 70 percent, Gholz estimates—but its apparent natural monopoly proved illusory. Its attempts to turn REEs into an economic weapon by exploiting low short-run elasticities only accelerated the development of alternative sources and new technologies.

By Ed Dolan

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:


Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage






Leave a comment

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News