• 2 minutes Rational analysis of CV19 from Harvard Medical School
  • 4 minutes While U.S. Pipelines Are Under Siege, China Streamlines Its Oil and Gas Network
  • 7 minutes Renewables Overtake Coal, But Lag Far Behind Oil And Natural Gas
  • 7 hours Tesla Begins Construction Of World’s Largest Energy Storage Facility
  • 4 hours Joe Biden the "Archie Bunker" of the left selects Kamala Harris for VP . . . . . . Does she help the campaign ?
  • 3 hours Will any journalist have the balls to ask Kamala if she supports Wall Street "Carried Interest" Tax Loophole
  • 1 day Trump Hands Putin Major Geopolitical Victory
  • 6 hours America Could Go Fully Electric Right Now
  • 1 day Those Nasty White People and Camping Racism
  • 4 hours In 1,267 days, Trump has made 20,055 false or misleading claims
  • 2 hours Buying votes is cool now.
  • 17 hours .
  • 13 hours The Truth about Chinese and Indian Engineering
  • 15 hours Brent above $45. Holding breath for $50??
  • 22 hours COVID&life and Vicious Circle: "Working From Home Is Not Panacea For Virus"
  • 2 days China wields coronavirus to nationalize American-owned carmaker
  • 16 hours The World is Facing a Solar Panel Waste Problem
  • 2 days Oil Tanker Runs Aground in Mauritius - Oil Spill
Colombian Oil Major Reports Surprise Profits Despite Market Downturn

Colombian Oil Major Reports Surprise Profits Despite Market Downturn

Ecopetrol’s ability to significantly dial…

Robinhood Investors Have A New Favorite Oil Stock

Robinhood Investors Have A New Favorite Oil Stock

Robinhood investors are an increasingly…

Michael McDonald

Michael McDonald

Michael is an assistant professor of finance and a frequent consultant to companies regarding capital structure decisions and investments. He holds a PhD in finance…

More Info

Premium Content

New Wind Turbines Taller Than The Empire State Building

Wind power may not be the cheapest, most efficient, or even most common form of renewable energy, but it is surely one of the most visually impressive methods of power generation. Anyone who has driven from Detroit to Toronto for instance can attest to the awe that comes from seeing dozens of windmills rising hundreds of feet into the air all turning in slow arcs with the wind. A new wind turbine design will put older smaller designs to shame though – if it can every get past the objections of environmentalists.

Canada, with lots of land, is an ideal place for many wind farms as are some of the most sparsely populated parts of the U.S. Those lightly populated and wide open spaces will be needed for the new turbines being designed by researchers at the University of Virginia, three other partner universities, and two U.S. national labs. The new turbines would rise more than 1,500 feet in the air and have blades more than 650 feet long. That height would make each of the turbines taller than the Empire State Building, and their rotating blades would occupy a plane roughly 1,300 feet wide. Turbines operating the new blades would generate 25 times as much power as current models – roughly 50 MW each. Related: An Output Freeze Is Still The Big Red-Herring For Oil

Having wind turbines that rise roughly a quarter mile into the air means all sorts of design challenges, which is why the project is still in the planning phases. Environmentalists for instance are opposed to such turbines because they would potentially kill birds who are migrating through the area. Researchers had talked about moving the turbines offshore to help accommodate the space needs of the design, but environmentalists are still raising concerns about bird impacts. To be fair though, almost every form of energy generation encounters severe criticism from environmentalists whether that generation is renewable or conventional.

From a simple logistics perspective, constructing a man-made structures over 1,000 feet tall is always challenging, but that is particularly true when considering wind turbines. Turbines are manufactured off site and then assembled on site. But the challenge of transporting 656 foot long turbine blades is likely insurmountable. Related: Horizontal Land Rig Count Summary 18th March 2016

Instead the blades will have to manufactured in small sections and transported one at a time. The design calls for these segmented blades to be able to spread out like a flower to capture more force from the wind as they rotate. The segments would be 131 to 164 feet in length – still long compared to a typical tractor trailer length of about 60-70 feet, but not unmovable as a 650 foot long section would be.

With wind power especially, the vast majority of the cost for the energy is in the upfront construction of the turbine. Thus, while these turbines will be much more costly than conventional turbines to construct, they will also generate significantly more energy. The real question then becomes which magnitude is larger. Related: After Years of Fracking, What do We Know?

Simulations suggest that the new turbines would generate 25 times more power than existing turbines. So if the new turbines cost less than 25 times as much to construct versus a traditional turbine, then they will make wind power more economical. If they cost more than 25 times as much, they will make wind power less economical.

Commercial wind turbines today generally cost $3-4 million (about $1.3 million to $2.2 million per MW – with the typical turbine generating 2 MW). So if the new turbines can come in for a cost of perhaps $20M – not unrealistic given back of the envelope calculations – they could lower the cost of wind power by as much as 60 percent.

By Michael McDonald of Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:


Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage





Leave a comment
  • thom on March 22 2016 said:
    For all the good guys out there:
    windmills kill million of birds, poisons the producers of neodym and this stuff isnt ready to recycle in years to come.
  • ew-3 on March 22 2016 said:
    I take it they do not understand transmission line loss.

    You really need to locate power sources within 100 miles of the customer, 200 miles at most but it's not very efficient.
  • Keophus on March 22 2016 said:
    No one ever talks about the life cycle of these things either.

    It's simply assumed they will never wear out.

    Probably doesn't matter as long as "someone else" is paying for it.

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News