• 4 minutes Ten Years of Plunging Solar Prices
  • 7 minutes Hydrogen Capable Natural Gas Turbines
  • 10 minutes World looks on in horror as Trump flails over pandemic despite claims US leads way
  • 13 minutes Large gas belt discovered in China
  • 2 hours Would bashing China solve all the problems of the United States
  • 4 hours Model 3 cheaper to buy than BMW 3 series.
  • 25 mins Thugs in Trumpistan
  • 7 hours China To Boost Oil & Gas Exploration, As EU Prepares To Commit Suicide
  • 5 hours Pompeo's Hong Kong
  • 6 hours Yale University Epidemiologist Publishes Paper on Major Benefits of Hydroxchloroquine for High-risk Outpatients. Quacksalvers like Fauci should put lives ahead of Politics
  • 2 hours China’s Oil Thirst Draws an Armada of Tankers
  • 4 hours Coronavirus hype biggest political hoax in history
  • 18 hours US-China tech competition accelerates: on Friday 05/15 new sanctions on Huawei, on Monday 05/18 Samsung chief visits China
  • 3 hours Chicago Threatens To Condemn - Possibly Demolish - Churches Defying Lockdown
  • 17 hours Income report showing potential future spending and economic growth
  • 19 hours The CDC confirms remarkably low coronavirus death rate. Where is the media?
  • 1 day COVID 19 May Be Less Deadly Than Flu Study Finds
A Nightmare Scenario For Offshore Oil

A Nightmare Scenario For Offshore Oil

The offshore oil industry is…

Solar Stocks Are Leading The Energy Market Recovery

Solar Stocks Are Leading The Energy Market Recovery

Renewables stocks have outperformed the…

The World Has Too Many Oil Refineries

The World Has Too Many Oil Refineries

Several years of heightened investment…

Andy Tully

Andy Tully

Andy Tully is a veteran news reporter who is now the news editor for Oilprice.com

More Info

Premium Content

New Safety Feature: A Smart Car Programmed To Let You Die?

The first auto safety device probably was the padded dashboard, unless you count such basics as roofs and windshields. Whatever the case, such features have proliferated to seat belts, air bags, rear cameras and the like.

Now researchers at the University of Alabama, Birmingham (UAB), are studying what may be the ultimate in safety features, one that's also counter-intuitive: The self-driving car that would allow its own occupants to die if its computer determines that their number would be fewer than the people whose lives are threatened in a looming auto accident. Related: Could $12 Trillion Trigger A Renewables Revolution?

“Ultimately this problem devolves into a choice between utilitarianism and deontology,” – the ethical principal that “some values are simply categorically always true,” UAB alumnus Ameen Barghi, a bioethicist, tells the school's news department.

Let's step back for a moment and look at a dilemma that highlights this ethical problem. Classically it's known as the Trolley Problem: An employee in charge of a switch on a trolley track knows a train is due to pass by soon, but suddenly notices that a school bus full of children is stalled on that track. A look at the alternate route shows the employee's young child has somehow crawled onto that track.
His choice is either to save his child, or save the many children on the bus. Which is right?

Now shift this dilemma to a highway of the not-too-distant future. It is crowded with cars, many of them self-driving vehicles. Google, which already has been experimenting with such autos, says its cars can ably handle the risks of the road, and boasts that any accidents involving its cars have been caused by human error, not programming glitches. Related: Why Buffett Bet A Billion On Solar

So here's another example of the dilemma involving not trolleys but cars: A tire suddenly blows out on a self-driving vehicle, and the auto's computer must now decide whether to allow the car to careen into oncoming traffic or deliberately steer the car into a retaining wall. Does it base its choice on the benefit of its occupants, or the benefit of others who may outnumber them?

Here's how Barghi breaks it down: “Utilitarianism tells us that we should always do what will produce the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people,” he told the UAB news department. In this scenario, then, the car should be programmed to ram into the retaining wall, endangering its occupants but sparing others on the highway.

But then there's deontology, which we might call ethical absolutism. “For example, [deontology dictates that] murder is always wrong, and we should never do it,” Barghi says. In the Trolley Problem, deontology says that “even if shifting the trolley will save five lives, we shouldn’t do it because we would be actively killing one.” Related: U.S. Oil Glut An EIA Invention?

As a result, he said, a company that follows deontology shouldn't program self-driving cars to save others while sacrificing the life of its occupants.

There's no word how Barghi stands on the dilemma of the self-driving car or the Trolley Problem. The UAB graduate, who will enroll in Britain's Oxford University in the autumn as a Rhodes Scholar, seems more interested in studying and debating such predicaments than in solving them. He served as a senior leader on UAB's team in the Bioethics Bowl in April at Florida State University. His team won this year's national championship.

But here's a hint: In last year's Bioethics Bowl, Barghi's team also competed, arguing a related case, whether governments would be justified in banning human driving altogether if self-driving cars proved to be significantly safer than cars with human drivers. Barghi's team argued in favor of self-driving cars.

By Andy Tully Of Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:


Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage





Leave a comment
  • aed939 on June 28 2015 said:
    In order to gain the confidence of consumers in robots, self-driving cars must be completely loyal to its owners. It must make decisions that are consistent with the owners' own preferences, and that usually means that they value the lives of their children over stranger children.

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News