• 4 minutes Permian in for Prosperous and Bright Future
  • 7 minutes Amount of Oil Usage in the United States
  • 10 minutes America Could Go Fully Electric Right Now
  • 10 mins Kalifornistan, CO2, clueless politicians, climate hustle
  • 6 mins JP Morgan Christyan Malek, report this Summer .. . We are at beginning of oil Super Cycle and will see $190 bbl Brent by 2025. LOL
  • 10 hours Something wicked this way comes
  • 2 days US after 4 more years of Trump?
  • 24 hours Tesla Battery Day (announcements on technology)
  • 1 min Jake Gardner from Omaha wrongly charged with murder while protecting his business from rioters. . . . . . Kills himself
  • 1 day Why NG falling n crude up?
  • 2 days Ten Years of Plunging Solar Prices
  • 3 days Famine, Economic Collapse of China on the Horizon?
Is Iraq Turning Its Back On The OPEC Deal?

Is Iraq Turning Its Back On The OPEC Deal?

OPEC’s second-largest producer is ramping…

Will New Zealand Close Its Last Oil Refinery?

Will New Zealand Close Its Last Oil Refinery?

The Coronavirus pandemic has seriously…

Investors Are Pulling The Plug On Argentina’s Prized Shale Play

Investors Are Pulling The Plug On Argentina’s Prized Shale Play

Argentina’s prized Vaca Muerta shale…

Haley Zaremba

Haley Zaremba

Haley Zaremba is a writer and journalist based in Mexico City. She has extensive experience writing and editing environmental features, travel pieces, local news in the…

More Info

Premium Content

Pipeline Bottlenecks Cost Canadian Producers $20 Billion

Canada has plenty of oil, and demand is high, but the Canadian oil industry has nevertheless taken a major hit this year thanks to its persisting pipeline bottleneck. The Albertan oil industry has long been plagued by insufficient pipeline volumes but has not been able to fix the issue with any semblance of efficiency thanks to major bureaucratic and litigation-based delays on building new infrastructure like the long-delayed Trans Mountain pipeline expansion project.

With pipeline capacity maxed out, Canadian oil producers have run out of storage space, leading to a major glut in oil reserves with nowhere to go. This has forced Canada to sell their oil at a major discount. In fact, a new study released this week by conservative think tank the Fraser Institute calculates that Canadian oil producers missed out on a whopping $20.62 billion more than they earned this year thanks to their severely depressed prices. Compared to the West Texas Intermediate benchmark, in the last year Canadian heavy crude traded, on average, at a discount of $26.50 U.S. a barrel. This is a huge dive from the five-year preceding, when Canadian heavy crude traded at an average of just $11.90 U.S. a barrel less than West Texas Intermediate.

The pipeline capacity deficit has negatively impacted the Canadian economy in a number of ways. “Canada’s lack of adequate pipeline capacity has imposed a number of costly constraints on the country’s energy sector including overdependence on the US market and reliance on more costly modes of energy transportation,” states the Fraser Research Bulletin. “In 2018, these factors, coupled with the maintenance downtime at refineries in the US Midwest, resulted in significant depressed prices for Canadian heavy crude (Western Canada Select) relative to US crude (West Texas Intermediate) and other international benchmarks.”

Fraser Institute went on to say that their calculations also found that if Canadian oil had been able to be transported in volumes corresponding to their current levels of production instead of watching their oil glut balloon and prices drop accordingly, Western Canadian Select would have traded at an average price of $52.90 U.S. a barrel during 2018 instead of the actual average price from last year, which clocked in at just $38.30 a barrel. “In September 2018, western Canadian oil production reached 4.3 million barrels per day but the takeaway capacity on existing pipelines remained constant at around 3.9 million barrels per day,“ the think tank’s report states. Related: The Beginning Of The End For British Shale Gas

These revenue losses pose a significant threat to the health of the Canadian economy. Since oil is one of the country’s most valuable commodities for export, the Fraser Institute reports that the overall loss of revenue from the oil industry in 2018 represents approximately one percent of the nation’s gross domestic product (GDP).

Canada has not sat idly by as a significant portion of its GDP lays to waste, however. The Canadian government and the local Alberta government have made significant efforts to correct the price drops, with enforced production cuts among other strategies, and there were some immediate positive results stemming from these quick fixes, but ultimately these efforts are not sustainable as a long-term solution to Canada’s pipeline to production gap woes.

What Canada ultimately needs in order to solve its pipeline problem is just that--pipelines. There are a number of massive trans-national pipeline projects underway, but they have so far been hopelessly entangled in litigation and other persistent delays. Enbridge's Line 3 project is currently being held up by regulators in Minnesota, the Keystone XL expansion has faced one legal hurdle after the other with no end in sight, and the Trans Mountain expansion--which most experts consider to be the Canadian Oil industry’s best bet--has been held back due to environmental violations and insufficient cooperation and consultation with the Indigenous peoples who rightfully own the land that the pipeline would need to pass through.

By Haley Zaremba for Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:


Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage





Leave a comment
  • Randy Wester on May 05 2019 said:
    But don't all of those producer losses translate into someone else's gain? Gasoline and other refined products are not selling cheap, even in Alberta. So isn't it all being made back by transportation and refining? (Somewhere, not necessarily within Canada)
  • Aaron Warbrick on May 05 2019 said:
    Why is Alberta and the oil industry allowed to continue lying to Canadians?
    There is NO BOTTLENECK!!! In fact, there have been LESS THAN 20% of the normal tanker traffic out of Vancouver this year. So apparently, even with reduced sales, we still need to expand our output?
    No one is buying it, so we need to be able to transport more of it? Okay, that makes sense....

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News