• 4 minutes Will We Ever See 100$+ OIL?
  • 8 minutes Iran downs US drone. No military response . . Just Destroy their economy. Can Senator Kerry be tried for aiding enemy ?
  • 11 minutes Energy Outlook for Renewables. Pie in the sky or real?
  • 1 hour Iran Loses $130,000,000 Oil Revenue Every Day They Continue Their Games . . . .Opportunity Lost . . . Will Never Get It Back. . . . . LOL .
  • 1 min How is E&P of Marginal Oil on the UKCS Similar to the Shale Oil Operations in the US?
  • 6 hours Berkeley becomes first U.S. city to ban natural gas in new homes
  • 44 mins Iran Says It Arrested 17 CIA Spies, Some Sentenced To Death
  • 15 mins Oil Giant Saudi Arabia Is Set to Start First Wind-Power Plant
  • 5 hours N.Y. Governor Signs Climate Bill
  • 2 hours So You Think We’re Reducing Fossil Fuel? — Think Again
  • 15 hours Shale Oil will it self destruct?
  • 5 hours First limpet mines . . . . now fly a drone at low altitude directly at U.S. Navy ship. Think Iran wanted it taken out ? Maybe ? YES
  • 1 hour Renewables provided only about 4% of total global energy needs in 2018
  • 1 day EIA Reports Are Fraudulent : EIA Is Conspiring With Trump To Keep Oil Prices Low
  • 22 hours U.S. Administration Moves To End Asylum Protections For Central Americans
  • 41 mins Which is a better domain name for OAPEC?
  • 4 hours Today in Energy
Alt Text

The World Can’t Let Nuclear Energy Die

Despite wavering public sentiment and…

John Daly

John Daly

Dr. John C.K. Daly is the chief analyst for Oilprice.com, Dr. Daly received his Ph.D. in 1986 from the School of Slavonic and East European…

More Info

Premium Content

Indian Nuclear Power Plant Sparks International Fears

If the 1986 Soviet Chernobyl disaster and, more recently, the destruction of Japan’s 11 March 2011 six reactor Fukushima Daiichi Tokyo Energy Power Co. installation, proved anything to the global community, aside from frantic assertions by the authorities that the public threat was minimal, it was that radioactive pollution is a trans-national issue.

The latest international nuclear spat is occurring between Sri Lanka and India over the latter’s imminent completion of its Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant. India’s government has dismissed as "baseless" the reports here about radiation leaks at the yet to be commissioned Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant in Tamil Nadu, saying it has a robust regulatory mechanism to ensure safe operation, with an Indian High Commission statement stating, "These reports are totally baseless. There has been no radiation leak at the Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant. It is reiterated that safety is accorded utmost attention in Nuclear Power Plants and encompasses the entire gamut of activities associated with these NPPs," adding that various works and commissioning tests and regulatory procedures are progressing, in line with oversight by India’s Atomic Energy Regulatory Board. The AERB reviews the various reports of performance tests and accords clearance for the next stage to ensure safe operation.

Related article: Who will Pay for Nuclear Power Plant Cleanup?

The facility is a poster child for India’s desperate efforts to ramp up its electrical generating facilities. India sees nuclear power as a shortcut to alleviating its energy shortages, adding Kudankulam to its current six NPPs, containing 20 reactors which generate 4,780 megawatts, with an additional seven NPPs expected to generate an additional 5,300 megawatts. The $2.5 billion, Kudankulam NPP in Tamil Nadu state will house six 1,200 megawatt and two 1,000 megawatt reactors.

Kudankulam NPP has been controversial since its inception. Last August no less a personage than Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh questioned India’s Department of Atomic Energy about liability for the NPP and who will pay if there is a mishap at the Kudankulam NPP. Adding to the anxieties of Indian nuclear power proponents is the fact that Singh is also India’s Minister for Atomic Energy.

The question of liability also extends to one of India’s closest trading partners, the Russian Federation, whose Atomstroieksport company constructed the NPP. When in 1988 an agreement for the Kudankulam NPP was signed between India and the (then) USSR for Kudankulam’s number 1 and 2 reactors, India had yet to draft a Nuclear Liability Bill, so the contract maintained that the Indian side, as the operator, would be fully responsible for any damage caused by a nuclear incident.

But the Nuclear Liability Bill legislation was passed in 2010 and provided that the supplier is also liable if the equipment is faulty. So, under the Nuclear Liability Bill, the operator, India, can claim damages from the supplier in such a case. The Russians have sought that the provisions of the pre-Nuclear Bill agreement of 2008 be extended to the next phases, unit 3 and 4, of the project as well and have brought this up at several high-level bilateral meetings, but Singh is resisting.

Related article: Iran Announces Discovery of Huge Uranium Deposits

Back to Sri Lanka.

On 21 February the Indian High Commission in Colombo dismissed Sri Lankan media reports on leaks having developed in critical equipment of the Kudankulam NPP, stating, "The Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant is a state-of-the-art plant that is compliant with the highest safety standards available in the nuclear industry today. The safety measures instituted at the plant are of the highest order."

India and Sri Lanka have an ongoing dialogue on cooperation in nuclear energy, issues including in the areas of isotope hydrology, radio-tracer studies and dam safety, and an Indian delegation is scheduled to visit Sri Lanka in the near future for the second round of dialogue on these and other areas of potential cooperation, including safety.

So, obviously, nothing to see here – yet, move along.

By. John C.K Daly of Oilprice.com




Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage


Leave a comment
  • Sidharth Sankar on February 26 2013 said:
    Sri Lanka is facing heat from numerous countries, including the United States and EU, for alleged Human Rights abuses in the recently concluded civil war.

    India is caught in a bind: do we press Sri Lanka on Human Rights abuses, and consequently, have them invite China to establish a base there, or do we let it slide and have a friendly government to our South.

    Sri Lanka, for it's part, by raking up imaginary issues, would like to remind India that it can be nuisance.

    There has been no radiation leak at Kundankulam. However, that does not mean we can never have a radiation leak. This "incident" has more to do with Geo-politics than nuclear safety.
  • Matt Robinson on February 26 2013 said:
    "desparate"? "shortcut"? Spoken like a true anti-nuclear critic fearful of losing his shirt by betting on the wrong animal.

    India's nuclear program has been going for 20+ years, and has involved the international community every step of the way. Their eventual move to thorium fuel is a model for the rest of the world for real energy independence.

    That they would rather employ a low-emission high-density nuclear energy source over a high-emission lower-density energy source such as oil and coal does not make their efforts desparate or shortcut.
  • Amit on February 27 2013 said:
    what about 40 billion usd nuke plant by south korea which is being constructed at dubai... no fears
    china constructing more and more..... no fears
    usa operating more than 100 plants ... no fears
    canada offering nuke plants .... no fears

    completely safe NPP which is not even in seismic zone .... so much fear

    I bet if India says it will purchase plant for US and allies all the protests will just disappear ....

    NPP will be commissioned soon.
  • Mark chambers on February 27 2013 said:
    I believe it was 1986 that Chernobyl exploded, not 1984.
  • SA Kiteman on February 27 2013 said:
    Since India is so loaded with Thorium, they really should start working hard on Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactors (LFTRs) which are from all accounts the safest, lean, clean, green form of reliable power available today.

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play