• 4 minutes Drone attacks cause fire at two Saudi Aramco facilities, blaze now under control
  • 7 minutes China Faces Economic Collapse
  • 13 minutes Oil Production Growth In U.S. Grinds To A Halt
  • 15 minutes Iran in the world market
  • 18 minutes Ethanol, the Perfect Home Remedy for A Saudi Oil Fever
  • 1 min USA Wants Iran War -- Shooty Shooty More
  • 1 hour USA : Attack came from 'Iranian soil'. Pompeo to release 'evidence'.
  • 52 mins Collateral Damage: Saudi Disruption Leaves Canada's Biggest Refinery Vulnerable
  • 7 hours Never Bring A Rapier To A Gun Fight
  • 10 hours Bahrain - U.S.: Signed Deal To Buy Patriot Missiles
  • 1 hour Yawn... Parliament Poised to Force Brexit Delay Until Jan. 31
  • 12 hours One of the fire satellite pictures showed what look like the fire hit outside the main oil complex. Like it hit storage or pipeline facility. Not big deal.
  • 11 hours Trump Will Win In 2020 And Beyond..?
  • 14 hours Wonders of US Shale: US Shale Benefits: The U.S. leads global petroleum and natural gas production with record growth in 2018
  • 12 hours How OPEC and OECD play their role in setting oil price in light of Iranian oil sanction ?? Does the world agree with Iran's oil sanctions ???
  • 7 hours Aramco Production
Alt Text

Nuclear Power Dying A Slow Death

Global nuclear power capacity could…

Alt Text

U.S. Nuclear Has A Tough Road Ahead

High-profile disasters and a booming…

Charles Kennedy

Charles Kennedy

Charles is a writer for Oilprice.com

More Info

Premium Content

Cheap Gas Claims Another Nuclear Victim

Cheap natural gas from U.S. shale claimed another victim this week.

Entergy, a large integrated utility specializing in nuclear power, announced that it will be shutting down its Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station in 2019, citing “poor market conditions, reduced revenues and increased operational costs.”

The Pilgrim plant, located in Plymouth, Massachusetts, has a capacity of 680 megawatts, enough power to supply 600,000 homes in New England with electricity. However, the power plant has been undercut by cheap natural gas, as New England increasingly ties into shale gas from the Marcellus Basin in Pennsylvania.

Cheap gas is putting downward pressure on wholesale power prices, pushing them down to $10 per megawatt hour, levels that are unprofitable for the Pilgrim plant. Entergy blamed flaws in electricity markets, which policymakers have failed to address. For example, nuclear power provides baseload power, 24 hours per day, and is low-carbon. That should theoretically make the plant a key part of the region’s climate change strategy. But since there is no price on carbon, the Entergy plant is not compensated for providing clean energy.

And with an eye on cheap natural gas, the region is supporting the expansion of natural gas pipelines to increase access to the fuel, with the intention of sourcing a larger share of the region’s electricity supply from natural gas. Related: Ludicrous Proposal By Venezuela’s Maduro To Combat Oil Price Damage

At the same time, Entergy blames state policies that support renewable energy, which is further pushing down wholesale power prices.

Entergy expects the move to shut down the plant to be cash flow neutral or positive. However, that highlights the utility’s vulnerability – its portfolio is heavily weighted on nuclear power plants, which are coming under increasing financial pressure. Keeping plants in operation could end up costing Entergy more than shutting them down. Related: Case Builds For Argentina As The World’s Next Shale Hotspot

Entergy’s struggles illustrate the pressure facing nuclear power in the United States. Cheap natural gas, cheap wind power, energy efficiency (leading to low demand), and policies supporting renewable energy are all eroding the business case for nuclear power. The former CEO and Chairman of Exelon (another nuclear-heavy utility) said in July that the “proper market-driven answer” for some utilities is to shut their plants down.

In fact, Pilgrim won’t be the first. Dominion Resources shut down the Kewaunee nuclear power plant in Wisconsin in 2013. The Vermont Yankee nuclear power plant shut down at the end of 2014 (also owned by Entergy). Both cited low wholesale power prices, mostly driven by cheap gas.

As renewable energy continues to make advances, and natural gas prices remain at low levels, there could be nothing but trouble ahead for nuclear assets.

By Charles Kennedy of Oilprice.com

More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:




Download The Free Oilprice App Today

Back to homepage



Leave a comment

Leave a comment




Oilprice - The No. 1 Source for Oil & Energy News
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play