ãã·ã¥ã»ã·ã§ãããã¯ã«ããMishTalk
ä»æ¥ã®åã¯EPAãã: çç´ æç²ã¯èªå·±è³é調éã§ããã¨ããã¦ãã¾ãï¼IRAã®è£å©éã®ãããã§ï¼ãããããè£å©éããã£ã¦ãã§ãã¾ãããåé»ã¨é»æ°æéã®ä¸æãäºæ³ããã¾ãã
ã³ã¹ãä¸æãåºåä½ä¸ã®è¦æ ¼ä¸å¼
EPAã®ãã¥ã¼ã¹ãªãªã¼ã¹ã«è©³ç´°ã«è¿«ãã¾ããããã¤ãã³ã»ããªã¹è¡æ¿åºãåç³çæç«åçºé»æããã®æ±æãåæ¸ããããã®è¦æ ¼ä¸å¼æçµæ±ºå®
ãæ¬æ¥ãEPAã¯ãæ°åå¤åã«åãçµã¿ãå ¨ã¦ã®ã³ãã¥ããã£ã大æ°ãæ°´åãè¿é£ã®æ±æããä¿è·ãããã¤ãã³ã»ããªã¹è¡æ¿åºã®ãã¸ã§ã³ãå®ç¾ã§ãã¦èªãã«æã£ã¦ãã¾ããã¨EPAé·å®ã®ãã¤ã±ã«ã»Sã»ãªã¼ã¬ã³ãè¿°ã¹ã¾ããããEPAã¯ãæ±æãåæ¸ããªãããé»åä¼ç¤¾ãè³¢æãªæè³ãè¡ããå ¨ç±³ã®äººã ã«ä¿¡é ¼æ§ã®é«ãé»åãæä¾ãç¶ããããããã«ããããã«ããããã®è¦æ ¼ãåããããããéæã§å æ¬çãªæ¹æ³ã§éçºãã¦ãã¾ããã
ç¾åã®ç³çç«åçºé»æã¨æ°ãã天ç¶ã¬ã¹ç«åçºé»æåãã®æçµã«ã¼ã«ã¯ãé·æéé転ãè¨ç»ãã¦ãããã¹ã¦ã®ç³çç«åçºé»æã¨ãã¹ã¦ã®æ°ãããã¼ã¹ãã¼ãã®ã¬ã¹ç«åçºé»æããããããã®çç´ æ±æã90ï¼ å¶å¾¡ãããã¨ãä¿è¨¼ãã¾ãã
æçµçãªæåºéè¦æ ¼ã¨ã¬ã¤ãã©ã¤ã³ã¯ãåççãªã³ã¹ãã«ããã¦çç´ æ±æãå¤§å¹ ã«åæ¸ãã¾ããæãé·æéé転ããã¦ããæ¢åã®ç³çã¦ãããã¨æãå¤ã使ç¨ããã¦ããæ°ããã¬ã¹ã¿ã¼ãã³åãã®æè¯ã®æåºåæ¸ã·ã¹ãã ã¯ãçç´ æç²ããã³è²¯ç/ä¿ç®¡ï¼CCSï¼ã«åºã¥ãã¦ãã¾ã - çºé»æã«ç´æ¥é©ç¨ã§ããå©ç¨å¯è½ã§ã³ã¹ãåçãªæåºå¶å¾¡æè¡ã§ãããçºé»æããã®äºé ¸åçç´ æåºã90ï¼ åæ¸ã§ãã¾ãã
CCSæè¡ã®è²»ç¨ä½æ¸ã¨ç¶ç¶çãªæ¹åã«å ãã¦ããã¤ãã³å¤§çµ±é ã®ã¤ã³ãã¬åæ¸æ³ããã®ç¨å¶åªéæªç½®ã«ãããä¼æ¥ãCCSã®ã³ã¹ãã®ã»ã¨ãã©ãç¸æ®ºã§ãã¾ããEPAã®åæã«ããã¨ãã»ã¯ã¿ã¼ã¯ãCCSããã®ä»ã®æåºåæ¸æè¡ã®ã³ã¹ããä½ä¸ãã¦ãããã¨ãããé»åä¾¡æ ¼ã«ã»ã¨ãã©å½±é¿ãä¸ããã«åºæºã«é©åã§ããã¨äºæ³ããã¾ããã¾ããEPAã¯ãé»åä¼ç¤¾ãã°ãªããã®ä¿¡é ¼æ§ãæºãããªãããé»åéè¦ã®å¢å ãèæ ®ããéã§ããåºæºãéµå®ã§ããã¨çµè«ä»ãã¦ãã¾ãã
EPAã®æçµè¦å
EPAã®æçµè¦åã¯ãã£ãã®1,020ãã¼ã¸ã§ããçç´ æç²ã¨è²¯ç/ä¿ç®¡ï¼CCSï¼ã«ã¤ãã¦953åã®è¨åãããã¾ããã
ãã®953ã®è¨åã®ããã¤ãã調ã¹ã¦ã以ä¸ã®æ å ±ãè¦ã¤ããã¾ããã
CCSã¯ååã«å®è¨¼ãããæè¡ã§ããã declining costs of the technology and a substantial tax credit available to sources.
The first component of the BSER [Best System of Emission Reduction] for base load combustion turbines is highly efficient generation (based on the emission rates that the best performing units are achieving) and the second component for base load combustion turbines is utilization of CCS with 90 percent capture.
One of the key GHG [Greenhouse Gasses] reduction technologies upon which the BSER determinations are founded in these final rules is CCS-a technology that can capture and permanently store CO2 from fossil fuel-fired EGUs.
I confess. I did not read all 1020 pages and don't intend to. I have seen enough by reading through a dozen or so of the 953 references to CCS.
ReturnTurning to the Biden-Harris document, I note references to "reasonable cost" and "largely offset the cost of CCS." Thus CCS is admittedly not cost effective even with subsidies.
IISD Sustainable Development
For a rebuttal to the above Biden claims, please consider the International Institution for Sustainable Development article Why Carbon Capture and Storage Is Not a Net-Zero Solution for Canada's Oil and Gas Sector
The poor track record of CCS in Canada is part of a broader trend. According to the Global CC
APã«ããã¨ãåæ¥éç¨ä¸ã®CCSæ½è¨ã«ããçç´ ã®æç²ã®ä¸ççæé·ã¯äºæ³ãããé ãã¦ãã¾ãã2022å¹´9æç¾å¨ãä¸çä¸ã®å ¨ã»ã¯ã¿ã¼ã§åæ¥éç¨ä¸ã®CCSããã¸ã§ã¯ãã¯ããã30件ã§ã42.5Mtpaãæç²ãã¦ãã¾ããããã¯ãIEAï¼2009å¹´ï¼ãè¨å®ãã2020å¹´ã¾ã§ã®300Mtpaã®ç®æ¨ã«ã¯é ãåã³ã¾ãããææ¡ãããããã¸ã§ã¯ãã®ã»ã¨ãã©ã¯æ¤åããã¾ãã: 2020å¹´ã¾ã§ã«çç´ ã貯çããäºå®ã ã£ã149件ã®CCSããã¸ã§ã¯ãã®ãã¡ã100件以ä¸ããã£ã³ã»ã«ããããç¡æéä¸æ¢ããã¾ããï¼Abdulla et al.ã2020å¹´; Wang et al.ã2021å¹´ï¼ãç±³å½ã§ã¯ãæè¡ã¸ã®ä¼æ¥ãæ¿åºããã®å¤§å¹ ãªæè³ã«ãããããããææ¡ãããCCSããã¸ã§ã¯ãã®80ï¼ ä»¥ä¸ãå®ç¨æ®µéã«è³ãããé«ã³ã¹ããä½æè¡çæºåç¶æ ãä¿¡é ¼ã§ãã財åãªã¿ã¼ã³ã®æ¬ å¦ãåã³å¼ãæããããæ¿åºã®ã¤ã³ã»ã³ãã£ãã¸ã®ä¾åãåå ã§ãã
ã¤ã¾ããCCSã®æ¨é²è ã¯ç¹°ãè¿ãæè¡ãæåºç©ãåæ¸ããè½åã«ã¤ãã¦é大ãªç´æããã¦ãããCCSããã¸ã§ã¯ãã®å®æ½ã¯ä¸ååã§ããã¨è¨ãã¾ãã
CCSã¯ã¨ãã«ã®ã¼ããã³è³æ¬éç´åã§ããçç´ ãæç²ããã³å§ç¸®ããã®ã«æãå¤ãã®ã¨ãã«ã®ã¼ãå¿ è¦ã§ãããCO2ã輸éããã³è²¯èµããããã«ã追å ã®éãå¿ è¦ã§ãã
ãã¤ãã³EPAã®é»åé 給è¨ç»
ã¦ã©ã¼ã«ã¹ããªã¼ãã¸ã£ã¼ãã«ã¯CCSã®å½ä»¤ããã¤ãã³EPAã®é»åé 給è¨ç»ã¨å¼ãã§ãã¾ãã
ã¯ãªã¼ã³ã¨ã¢æ³ç¬¬111æ¡ã§ã¯ãEPAããé©åº¦ã«å®è¨¼ããããæé©ãªæåºåæ¸ã·ã¹ãã ãéãã¦åºå®æºããã®æ±æç©ãè¦å¶ã§ããã¨ããã¦ãã¾ããçç´ æç²ã¯æé©ã§ãé©åã«å®è¨¼ãããããã§ã¯ããã¾ãããæ¨å¹´æç¹ã§ãä¸çã§åæ¥è¦æ¨¡ã®ç³çç«åçºé»æã1ã¤ããçç´ æç²ã使ç¨ãã¦ããããã¬ã¹ç«åçºé»æã«è³ã£ã¦ã¯ä¸ã¤ãããã¾ããã§ããã
EPAã¯ã2021å¹´ã¤ã³ãã©æ³ã«ãããã¤ã³ãã¬åæ¸æ³ã®ç¨é¡æ§é¤ããã³è³éãçç´ æç²ã®ã奨å±ã¨å±éãä¿é²ããããã«ãªãã¨ãã¦ãã¾ããããããç³ççºé»æã§ãã®æè¡ãå¹æçã«ããã«ã¯ãè£å©éã¯2åãã3åå¿ è¦ã§ããçç´ æç²ã¯çºé»æã®å¹çãä½ä¸ãããããã«ããã³ã¹ããä¸ããã¾ãã
çç´ æç²ã«ããçºé»æã§çæãããé»åã®20ï¼ ãã25ï¼ ã使ç¨ããããã使ç¨å¯è½ãªé»åéãæ¸å°ãã¾ããããã¯åãé»åéãæä¾ããããã«ããå¤ãã®çºé»æ©ãå¿ è¦ã«ãªããã¨ãæå³ãã¾ããããããæ°ããã¬ã¹ç«åçºé»æã¯å»ºè¨ããã¾ããããªããªããã®ãã¯ããã¸ã¼ã«ãã£ã¦ããããéçµæ¸çã«ãªãããã§ããã¸ã¬ã³ãã¨è¨ã£ã¦ãéè¨ã§ã¯ããã¾ããã
å¥ã®åé¡ã¯ãCO2ãå°ä¸ã®ç¹å®ã®å°è³ªæ§é ã«è²¯èµããå¿ è¦ããããã¨ã§ãããããã¯ä¸»ã«ä¸è¥¿é¨ã¨ã¡ãã·ã³æ¹¾å²¸ã«éä¸ãã¦ãã¾ããCO2ãæ³¨å ¥ããããã®æ°ããäºæ¸ã®è¨±å¯ã¯6å¹´ãããå ´åãããã¾ããCO2ã輸éãããã¤ãã©ã¤ã³ã¯ããã«é·ãæéãè¦ããããããã¾ãããç·ã®å£ä½ã¯ãç³æ²¹ã天ç¶ã¬ã¹ã¨åãããã«CO2ã®ãã¤ãã©ã¤ã³ã«å対ãã¦ãã¾ãã
ãããã¹ã¦ããæ°ãã製é ãã¼ãºã人工ç¥è½ãã¼ã ã«ä¼´ãéè¦ã®æ¥å¢ã®ä¸ã§è¥²æ¥ããã§ãããããããµã¹ã®é»å網éç¨è ã¯ä»é±ã2030å¹´ã®éè¦æé·äºæ¸¬ãæ¨å¹´ã®äºæ¸¬ã¨æ¯è¼ãã¦40,000MWå¼ãä¸ãã¾ãããããã¯ããã¥ã¼ã¨ã¼ã¯å¸ããã¤ã§ã使ç¨ããé»åã®ç´7åã«ç¸å½ãã¾ãã
ãããµã¹ã®é»åéè¦ã¯ããã¼ã¿ã»ã³ã¿ã¼ã製é ãã©ã³ããæå·ãã¤ãã³ã°ãããã³ç³æ²¹ã»ã¬ã¹è£ ç½®ã®é»åã«ããã次ã®6å¹´ã§ã»ã¼åå¢ããã§ãããããããµã¹ã®æ°æ¸©ã80度ãè¶ ããã¨ã網éç¨è ã¯çºé»æã«ã¡ã³ããã³ã¹ã®ããã«ã·ã£ãããã¦ã³ããªãããæ示ãã¾ãããå ¨å½ã®ã¢ã¡ãªã«äººã¯ãå¤ã«æ¸©åº¦è¨å®ãä¸ãã¦å®¶é»è£½åã稼åãããªãããã«æ示ãããããã«ãªã£ã¦ãã¾ãã
æ°ä¸»å ã®ä¸é¨è°å¡ããå½¼ãã®æ権è ã®çµæ¸çè² æ ã«æ°ã¥ãå§ãã¦ãã¾ãããã¼ã·ã¼ã»ã«ãã¿ã¼ããã³ãªã¼ã»ã¯ã¨ã©ã¼ãã¡ã¢ãªã¼ã»ãµãã©ã¼ã»ãã«ãã©ããã»ã³ãã»ã´ã³ã¶ã¬ã¹ãã¸ã£ã¬ãã»ã´ã¼ã«ãã³ä»£è°å£«ã¯å é±æ«ãEPAã®çºé»æè¦åã®æçµåã延æãããããã¤ãã³å¤§çµ±é ã«æ±ãã¾ãããããã¯ãé»æ°ã®æã®å±ããªãã»ã©é«ãä¾¡æ ¼åé¡ã¨ãé»åä¿¡é ¼æ§ã¸ã®å¢å ãããªã¹ã¯ãã¨ããæ¢åã®åé¡ã誤ã£ã¦æªåãããããªããããã¨è¿°ã¹ã¦ãã¾ãã
ãã¤ãã³æ°ã®æ°ããè¦åã¯ééããªãæ³çææ¦ãæãã§ãããããããã訴è¨ãé²è¡ããä¸ãé常ã«ä¸ç¢ºå®ãªç¶æ³ã¯ãå¿ è¦ã¨ãããæ°ããã¬ã¹ç«åçºé»æ
The leading economics blog online covering financial issues, geopolitics and trading.… More